I've been following the ebike forums: here are a couple of relevant comments.

BTW this particular ebike is not new, just "improved" - and is "purpose built" 
from standard parts (although Currie is well-know as a supplier of conversion 
kits).  They (Currie) do keep improving it slightly, almost monthly. The same 
bike for the same price is available from Amazon (where there are reviews from 
users)

http://www.amazon.com/Trailz-Electric-Mountain-26-Inch-Wheels/dp/B0017K2ZL4/ref=sr_1_10?ie=UTF8&s=sporting-goods&qid=1224427978&sr=8-10

First, the price is right - obviously since it is carried by Walmart, made with 
Chinese parts by Currie and assemble in California - and possibly of mediocre 
to decent quality. That remains to be seen. However, the "afficiandos" are 
dissing it due to some previous problems with the Currie branded controllers 
and the weight. This controller problem could be solved by now, but no one is 
sure.

Dr. Malcolm Currie founded the bike company - former
of Hughes Aircraft and Delco Electronics. I think they They have ten years
of sustained experience and unlike the many other ebike makers (which have 
folded) they know how to supply a good quality bike at a fair price. Plus they 
are constantly improving the model and sooner or later they will get it right 
(kind of like the Model T). This is from the company site.

http://www.currietech.com/html/07_ezip_main_prod.html

Second, the 450 watt motor is sufficient - and more powerful than many hub 
motors which can be as low as 300 watts -- but is it reliable? (i.e. good 
bearings and most of all - good controller?) It is pulling 70 pounds of bike 
which is about 15 pounds of weight "penalty" -- and that is the tradeoff for 
saving about $400 in the cost of batteries (over Lifepo).

It should be mentioned that the "controller" which can mean many things, 
depending on the motor characteristics - is the most critical part of an 
electric bike, especially when powered by lithium and when using a hub motor. 
This ezip design apparently puts less stress on the controller - which is good.

The battery is advanced SLA (sealed lead acid) - whereas the lightweight (and 
expensive choice) these days is called LifePo (lithium iron potassium oxide) - 
except for the big caveat that the ones made in China are inferior to the USA 
made variety. This is arguably due to the patent situation - as the Chinese are 
apparently infringing. Advice: do not buy Chinese manufactured LifePo without a 
full rock-solid warranty from the seller - as the previous factory warranties 
have been worthless.

By far, after all is said and done, the best "value" of available batteries - 
BY FAR - even for ebikes where weight is arguably most important, is the 
advanced SLA battery... a bit surprising, wouldn't you say? 

The weight penalty is far less important to most consummer than the extreme 
price differential. And there is really zero prospect of this "comparative 
value" situation changing soon. 

All in all, this is a very good deal - maybe the best avialable - for the short 
commute in areas of decent weather. But do not expect the battery to last more 
than two years if recharged daily.

Jones




----- Original Message ----
From: Jed Rothwell <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

This costs $400, which is a lot cheaper than other purpose built
electric bicycles I have seen.

See:

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.do?product_id=8467096

I saw one of these parked at the grocery store yesterday. It seems
like a solid machine, with a simple electric motor mounted low on the
frame, on the back wheel left chain stay, level with the wheel hub.
The battery is 18 lb, mounted below on the rear cargo rack, leaving
the rack free for other stuff on top. It is good to keep the weight
low to the ground.

It has a rear derailleur only, with 7 sprockets, with a fairly wide
range of gears. Enough for an electric bike.

Specs:

E-Zip 2008 Trailz Hybrid Electric Bike, Men's:

Easy comfort design
PAS/TAG technology: use with motor only or with motor assist power
Rack-mounted SLA battery for easy swapping
Top speed: 18 mph/29km/h
Range: 15 miles
7-speed geared system with Shimano Acera rear derailleur
Rear rack:

Carry groceries, other goods
Add a second battery (sold separately) for added range

Motor:

450W of power
DC Earth magnet motor

. . .

Shipping weight 81 lbs

My Lafree electric bicycle is on the fritz again. It might be cheaper
to buy one of these than to replace it. This looks a little lighter
than the Lafree, which is no longer made. The motor on this new bike
is slightly more powerful than the Lafree (450 versus 400 W). The
battery is lighter and the range shorter.

This looks practical for people who don't have much money and have to
commute 5 or 10 miles. I think the one I saw belongs to one of the
cashiers at the grocery store, who has been commuting on a regular,
beat-up bicycle.

- Jed

Reply via email to