Standing Bear wrote:
On Monday 17 September 2007 11:08, Jed Rothwell wrote:
My daily blog search for "cold fusion" brought up a depressing
interview about Russ George and Planktos. See:
http://www.ecoshock.org/2007/09/planktos-ii-intervention.html
I should stop searching for blogs and commenting in them, because the
blog audience is either small or exceedingly skeptical. There are
few hyperlinks from my blog comments to LENR-CANR.org. In other
words, when I leave a message suggesting that people read papers or
click on LENR-CANR.org, only a handful of people do that. The numbers
seem to range from 0 to around 4. I suppose this is good news, since
it means nobody reads these blogs but me.
- Jed
Did not read very far into that particular blog, but did pick up on the idea
to stimulate algae with iron dust. That implies that some algae at least
feed from iron.
My understanding is that the iron is just fertilizer. I.e., it's a
building block used in making more algae, not an energy source.
It's one of a host of "trace" minerals which are needed, including such
things as copper. It happens, however, that it's needed in relatively
large quantities by algae (and by azaleas, for whatever that's worth)
and it's in short supply in the sea. So short, in fact, that it's the
limiting factor in algae growth, in at least SOME places, at least SOME
of the time. Whether it's the limiting factor in MOST places MOST of
the time is another question.
And there is something else, as well -- I seem to recall that iron
compounds used on land tend to acidify the soil. This is also a big
deal for azaleas and other acid-loving plants. But playing games with
the pH in the sea could have a major impact on a lot of things.
And of course we also should ask if there are plants which actively
DISLIKE the extra iron. Again, it's not an energy source, it's more
like a vitamin pill, and maybe some things are happier without it.
Google of "green/up iron fertilizer" turns up a lot of stuff about
lawns, including this little snippet:
A green up fertilizer containing 13.5% ferrous sulphate in a fine
form to assist in controlling moss...
That seems a little disturbing, so I googled "fertilizer moss iron", and
got over 400,000 hits, with such quotes as:
... put iron on to kill the moss ...
So apparently moss, at least, dislikes iron compounds pretty intensely.
Are there any relatives of moss living in the sea -- relatives we
might be fond of, and which might be offended by dumping iron in the
ocean? I dunno. Do the folks at Planktos know? I dunno that either.
All this points up the likelihood that, like cane toads, introducing
large amounts of iron into the ocean is likely to have unforeseen side
effects, and may or may not actually do much for the original problem.
This means that those algae could be significant players
in ship exterior hull corrosion. It gets into shipping lanes in the open
ocean and the shipping of 'walmart' imports into America could be at risk as
huge iron container ships get infested. Be odd if American industrial
prosperity is brought back by such a humble organism.
Bear