>Perhaps it should be censored because it is dangerous, but not
>because it is stupid. Pardon me for putting it this way, but
>censoring stupidity is a stupid idea. There are two problems with
>this: it violates academic freedom, and no one can be certain what is
>stupid and what isn't. There are borderline cases of pornography --
>pictures that some people would call porn but others would not, but
>the ambiguity is greater when judging stupid or smart.

Jed;

Your point is valid and understood, yet how many people will try something
that they would not have conceived of on their own, yet the idea formed when
seeing it done by someone else? These are followers that are not budding
scientists.

How many times has our media covered horrific acts by someone to be followed
by what is coined "A Copy Cat"?

I do indeed hate censorship and fully believe in ones rights, yet avenues
are available which direct in a meaningful and educational way. If this were
not true then schools would serve no purpose, let everyone learn from
experience and copying their peer.

Excellent response, yet I stand by my statement, showing potentially
dangerous acts such as I described, should not be available as they now are.

Why might one wonder why the instructions for building a bomb be frowned
upon when someone blowing up a container of HHO be okay?




-----Original Message-----
From: Jed Rothwell [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Monday, September 17, 2007 9:28 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: RE: [Vo]:This is a must see, please


Stiffler Scientific wrote:

>Mistakes are human nature and will always exist, yet overt stupidity should
>not be allowed. In my opinion I actually feel YouTube should look into
>censoring as they do Porn, those that abuse H2+O2 in the way they are.

Perhaps it should be censored because it is dangerous, but not
because it is stupid. Pardon me for putting it this way, but
censoring stupidity is a stupid idea. There are two problems with
this: it violates academic freedom, and no one can be certain what is
stupid and what isn't. There are borderline cases of pornography --
pictures that some people would call porn but others would not, but
the ambiguity is greater when judging stupid or smart.

Speaking of censorship, here is a blogger who wants the Congress to
crack down hard on the Navy for allowing cold fusion research:

http://www.flightglobal.com/blogs/the-dewline/2007/09/business-week-investig
ates-ear.html

Now that a little research is allowed, you can expect many such
people to emerge from under their rocks. When cold fusion research
was merely a hypothetical scourge -- not something actually practiced
-- these people attacked it only in principle, and did not that
specific people be censored (Pam Boss in this case).

- Jed

Reply via email to