On Sep 11, 2007, at 10:22 AM, Michael Foster wrote:



I am always amused by triboelectric series tables.  The people who put
these out usually have absolutely no idea what they are talking about.
The position of lead on this table is complete nonsense.

Yes, it was surprising to see lead up there with the notorious cat fur. I've never seen any static effects whatsoever associated with lead. It must be active with some material?


Other gross
errors include acrylic, polyester and styrene on the negative side.
The vast majority of acrylics, and there are thousands, tend to go
positive when rubbed with almost anything, including cat fur and rabbit fur. Styrene is interesting because in can go either way depending on the
conditions, however, it usually goes positive. Styrofoam tends to go
negative whereas crystal styrene almost always tends positive, even though
they are chemically identical.

Glass is interesting. Most modern glasses are difficult to charge. One of the best ways to charge glass is to use aluminum foil, much better than
those materials listed on the negative side of Wikipedia's series.  Of
course you have to keep the glass against a conductive surface, wood, Formica, metal, etc., while you are rubbing the glass so that the charge is kept at
low voltage. You then pick up the sheet of glass and it hisses its
positive charge into the nearest grounded object.

Sounds like you have done a lot of experimenting along these lines.

Any experience with gasses that have triboelectric effects?


That's clear glass. Frosted, ground, or sandblasted glass tends to go
negative. The only reason I bring all this up is that the conventional
ideas as to what constitutes electron sources are not necessarily valid.
Several metals and other substances dutifully listed on triboelectric
series are in their positions based on assumptions, hearsay, and errors.

It also seemed to me strange zinc, one of the more electrochemically active metals, was not even listed.


So goes the rest of science and most other human endeavors.

The problem with the triboelectric tables is they are subjective, not quantitative, and thus probably haven't had use or scrutiny. They are not even in my 74th Edition CRC Handbook of Physics and Chemistry. Most of the other stuff in there seems pretty reliable. It has to be for the most part, because it is used for engineering and lives can be at stake.



"There is someting fascinating about science.  One gets such wholesale
returns of conjecture out of such a trifling investment of fact."
   --Mark Twain

Gee, I thought that was a good thing!  8^)

It is indeed surprising how such a large amount of physics, especially 19th century physics, is based on so few experiments. It is also wonderful how understanding such a few basic laws gives us so much insight unavailable to generations past.

Horace Heffner
http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/



Reply via email to