On 12/7/2007 10:57 AM, Jones Beene wrote: > Horace Heffner wrote: > >> However, there will still be losses due to core and magnet heating, even >> if no power is drawn from the coils. Further, as soon as the coils draw >> power, the motion of shield is retarded because the energy from opening >> the flux hole is less. > > > The so-called flux-gate is an old concept which has never come close to > *replicated* OU in over 100 years of trying. There are hints and > glimpses, but that is all. In effect, it can be analogized to a rotating > transformer. > > However, any common solid state transformer will do better (99%+). > > Here is an older patent, '75 which is functionally identical to the > Harry's present thinking, and it cites even older patents: > > http://www.rexresearch.com/ecklin/ecklin.htm > > There are some patents involving flux switching going back to the > previous century. Mark Goldes has mentioned that the Gary patent: > > http://www.linux-host.org/energy/tgarymo.htm > > has pretty good historical verification, but AFAIK, no one has ever > replicated it in modern times. > > AS "logical" and enticing as it may sound, my advice to Harry is: don't > waste your time with this one, unless you can independently find a > natural asymmetry. > > It has always seemed alluring that the immense lifting power of a PM > "should" be able to be switched or gated somehow, and that flux would > substitute for a lossy electromagnet. Steorn is only the latest victim > of this false hope. > > I believe that Horace has given the correct, or partially correct > rationale, for why this concept is doomed - the motion of the shield > will always be retarded by the same forces which would, in theory, > provide the hoped-for gain or anomaly. No free lunch there. > > Here is a crude way of stating the underlying logical problem: Flux > "lines" provide the (metaphorical) power source, yet flux lines will > ALWAYS "jump" out of any preferred (ferromagnetic) pathway like iron, > into surrounding space, if the only alternative is to provide more > energy then they can possess thermodynamically. > > To make the thing work - you must find some natural asymmetry.
I see gravity as providing the asymmetry...but I am not exactly sure how. Thanks for the links. I quickly scanned the pages but the systems shown do not appear to depend on gravity in any essential way. Harry > There are > few in magnetism, alone. There are some small asymmetries in chemistry. > There is the possibility that compound or combinatory systems in which > both chemistry and magnetism are used, for instance, or mechanics and > chemistry (i.e. sonochemistry) are not subject to the same thermodynamic > impediments as the pure system. > > BTW there is a technical definition for fluxgate, related to > magnetomerty, which is slightly different than the free-energy usage. > > Jones >

