OrionWorks wrote:
Viewing an interesting Wikipedia article "First Flying Machines", See:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_flying_machine
lists a surprising number of people involved.
That is interesting. Actually, many people who are not listed made
important contributions, especially Chanute and Langley. It took me a
while to figure out why they are not listed. It is because they
themselves did not ride on man-carrying flying machines. Chanute
helped design many machines (including the Wrights) and he wrote the
most important book about aviation before Kitty Hawk, "Progress in
Flying Machines." This is listed in the article, and available on line:
http://invention.psychology.msstate.edu/i/Chanute/library/Prog_Contents.html
Langley was the first to make a sustained flight with large powered
model airplanes in 1895 and 1896.
The Wrights read extensively, and they were close friends with
Chanute, so they knew about earlier work. They gave generous credit
to the people who came before them, including several not listed here
who contributed only theories, or flew only models.
I didn't see them mentioned in the Wiki article but I seem to recall
that there had also been a federally funded U.S. project to build a
powered plane. Millions of dollars were spent building a prototype
only to see the results crash into a lake on its maiden flight.
This refers to Langley's 1903 attempted flights. (On the Potomac
River, not a lake.) Langley was the Secretary of the Smithsonian
Institution. The War Department contributed $50,000 and the
Smithsonian came up with $20,000 for the project. That equals about
$1.6 million in 2005 dollars. The flights were an utter failure, and
were widely ridiculed in the press. The aircraft was much too fragile
and it was not airworthy even if it had been stronger. It was a
scaled-up version of the 1896 model. I do not think that Langley
contributed much to aviation after 1896. See:
http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/RothwellJthewrightb.pdf
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Pierpont_Langley
What I'm leading up to here is the observation of a historical
pattern where inventors of some new innovative technology, more
often than not, have many, MANY competitors nipping at their heels.
Official historical accounts, OTOH, tend to gloss over the many
players & contributors who were simultaneously involved in the same
quest. Official historical accounts often tend to focus on a single
"winner" as if they the only game in town.
In many cases this is true, but aviation happens to be a clear-cut
case where there were no serious competitors. No one was close to the
Wrights. Serious research petered out in the late 19th century after
Lilienthal and Pilcher were killed. No one other than the Wrights had
any decent wind-tunnel data, or a detailed grasp of the physics, or
any ability to model aircraft for performance and stability, or any
idea how to control an aircraft.
As Crouch put it, in 1900, other than the Wrights the field was
"moribund." Some modern engineers and historians say that other
groups should have been closer, and engineering the airplane was not
as difficult as people thought it would be. Talented engineers and
scientists were discouraged because most people in 1903 were
convinced that heavier-than-air flying machines were physically
impossible. Simon Newcomb was the leading scientist who made this
claim -- a 1903 version of Frank Close. He was a good physicist, but
his reasons for claiming that flight is impossible were risible.
We know that many talented engineers had enough skill to invent the
airplane because after the Wrights work became widely known in 1908,
many other people such as Sopwith and Sikorsky soon learned to make
airplanes better than the Wrights'. I do not think Sikorsky had much
original source information. I gather he independently reinvented
things based on photographs and descriptions, rather than an
in-person examination of the airplane or the 1906 patent.
Still, the Wrights were fantastically talented as theoreticians,
experimentalists, craftsmen and sportsmen. Modern experts consider
them geniuses, "of the theoretical quality of Leonardo, Kepler,
Copernicus, Einstein, or the practical inventiveness of Steinmetz and
Edison." (H. Combs.) (I think Einstein is an exaggeration but Kepler
or C. P. Steinmetz are reasonable comparisons.) They filled notebooks
with advanced mathematics that no engineering undergraduate today
would attempt without a computer, and their wind-tunnel design and
data quality was not exceeded until the 1920s. Before they cut wood
to construct the first propeller, they modeled it mathematically and
predicted its performance correctly within 1%! In 1908, their
competitors were using motors with five times the horsepower but such
inferior propellers that they produced less thrust than the Wrights' propeller.
Others might have discovered flight, but the Wrights did discover it.
For that matter, others might have invented the transistor, but the
people at Bell Labs did. Mizuno might have discovered cold fusion --
which was staring him in the face at one point -- but he didn't, and
Fleischmann and Pons did.
I know hundreds of people who are working on cold fusion, and many
others who have worked on it but are now retired or dead. To be
brutally honest, I think only a handful of these people have made
original, important contributions. The others have done "me too"
replications. But, you need a large crowd of people to make progress.
A few people will stand out from the crowd, and you cannot predict
who they will be. Even the person who makes the contribution is
unaware of his or her ability beforehand; after their first
disappointing glider flights of 1901, the Wrights predicted that man
would not fly in their lifetimes. In the mid-19th century, a small
group of artists painted splendid impressionist paintings, which are
the most popular works in museums today. We can thank two things for
impressionism: 1. The camera, which showed people how the world
really looks for the first time in history, and 2. The immense
popularity of painting at that time. That small group became famous,
but hundreds of others painters did not become famous, including many
enthusiastic amateurs. Without this vast crowd of artists, the
geniuses would not have become interested in art in the first place,
and they would not have been inspired or sustained by their fans.
I'm wondering if official historical accounts may soon repeat
itself, generating the same pattern of misleading information as we
witness the race to build the first ZPE OU "motor."
Let's wait to see if anyone actually makes a ZPE OU motor. I doubt it
will happen. Unlike Newcomb and Close, I do not pretend to have
sophisticated technical justifications for this belief. I doubt it
because it is an apparent violation of the conservation of energy,
because no one has done it yet as far as I know, despite strenuous
efforts by lots of people.
- Jed