Horace Heffner wrote:

Agreed ...yet one should not forget that the neutron itself is diamagnetic.

This is news to me. The neutron has a large magnetic moment. It's a pretty strong magnet. I do know that in scattering experiments neutrons respond strongly to diamagnetic effects induced on the sample by magnets, thus neutrons are useful in mapping diamagnetic atom lattice positions. Where does this info come from?

I should have qualified that to say something like 'functional diamagnets' or 'spin oriented diamagnetism.' Diamagnetism is generally understood to be due to the non-cooperative behavior of orbiting electrons when exposed to an applied magnetic field. Of course, with no orbiting electrons, neutrons are excluded by definition, but they will be repelled by a magnetic field in one of the two possible spin states.

Diamagnetic substances are generally composed of groups of atoms which have no net magnetic moments (ie., all the orbital shells are filled and there are no unpaired electrons). However, when exposed to a field, a negative magnetization is produced and thus the susceptibility is negative.

OK. Moving on to non-atoms which can act the same way. At one time Oak Ridge was working on a neutron beam line which used what can be called spin aligned diamagnetism - if I am wording this correctly. Neutrons do have a magnetic moment and can interact with a magnetic field, B, by the dipole interaction where the magnetic moment of the neutron is oriented anti-parallel to the spin of the neutron. True diamagnets would have zero net magnetic moment, regardless of spin.

Here is the quote, but the link I have is apparently dead: "Since the neutron is a spin-1/2 particle, it has two possible quantum spin states, oriented parallel and anti-parallel to the magnetic field. When the neutron spin is aligned parallel to the magnetic field, the interaction energy is positive. Regions of high magnetic field repel neutrons in the parallel or “low-field-seeking” spin state." That would be the functional equivalent of a diamagnet. And the concept was to use this feature in a neutron beam line since the repelling action did not reorient the spin. But again - if we define a diamagnet in terms of orbiting electrons - the neutron is excluded. By definition.

Similarly, neutrons with spins anti-parallel to the magnetic field have a negative interaction energy, and are attracted to regions of higher magnetic field and are called “high field seekers”. This would make any beam line rather fragile, I suppose, since a spin change will be counter productive, and perhaps they (ORNL) gave up on it.

Jones


Reply via email to