Also I don't want to hear anymore about Levy and any other so called scientific experiment unless the experiment was fully open and under the control of the experimenter.
I don't know of any real experiment that is done in that way. It is true that in some double blinded experiments the experimenters are not aware of some of the conditions of the experiment but we are talking about something completely different here. I already addressed how scientists are not trained to detect direct fraud. So Levy and all the other scientific experiments on the eCat are null and void unless the scientists had control of the details of the experiment that it was not the case at all. Giovanni On Sun, Aug 14, 2016 at 4:10 PM, Giovanni Santostasi <[email protected]> wrote: > A.ashfield: > > "Ad hominem" attacks. To quote a famous immortal scene from the "Princess > Bride": "You keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it > means". > > I didn't attack anybody at hominem. I didn't put down Penon not to have a > PhD. > I simply stated that Rossi saying he has a Doctorate is not true and that > is at least sloppy and probably misleading. > > It doesn't reflect negatively on me at all. > > So let me reflect this back at you given you don't understand what ad > hominem attack is and instead you are using your supposed experience to > make an argument (and trying to disqualify my arguments too as a > consequence) and therefore committing another known fallacy , i. e. > "argument from authority". > > Giovanni > > > > > > On Sun, Aug 14, 2016 at 3:52 PM, a.ashfield <[email protected]> > wrote: > >> Giovanni, >> Your string of ad hominem attacks do nothing to clarify the issues and >> reflect badly on you. >> >> I find Dr. Levi's 18 hour test of an E-Cat in 2011, without steam, >> finding a COP 15 -20kW peaking at 130 kW is good proof that the E-Cat >> produces considerable excess heat. As I've said, the performance of the 1 >> MW plant has yet to be proven. >> >> Having headed engineering for large corporations and later consulting >> around the world, doing due diligence for organizations like GRI, EPRI, >> OECD and the World Bank, I have considerable experience in judging people >> and new technologies. >> What experience do you have? >> >> >
