SVJ,
I understand where you are coming from and Jed maybe right. But I don't
consider it proven yet and object to the definitive way Rossi is accused
of fraud before the court case is held. We should have more information
next month, in particular IH's response to the charge.
Several of Jed's charges such as the released heat being lethal and that
it was just Rossi preventing IH from visiting the customer do not stand
up to scrutiny. His figures on calorimetry from IH have not been
shown. Mats Lewan claims others who have seen Penon's report say that
the only way the plant did not produce a high COP is if Penen wrote a
deliberately fraudulent report. So it looks like the claim is that
quite a number of people were criminal frauds. Rossi, his team. the
customer and Penon. Jed later claimed Rossi's own figures showed the COP
was one. I don't see that. Recently Rossi has stated the steam was
superheated. We won't know the truth without more data.
It should be possible to measure the input and output of a black box.
Penon is an expert professional, hired by both parties, and there is no
reason to think he did not do that unless FACTS surface to contradict
it. The court case should make the answer known and we should wait for
that.
