Nicholas Cafarelli <[email protected]> wrote:

> The actions he took cause some to claim that all his work must now be
> suspect.  I assert that such a claim violates accepted scientific protocol.
>

Yes. Right. He admitted that as well.



> If I make one unreasoned action, I create one data point for observing
> scientists.
>

One action? It probably took him an hour. It wasn't a momentary slip of the
finger. It was not inadvertent.

How many times would he have to do this sort of thing before you conclude
he is acting strangely? Do you know any other scientists who would do this?
I don't. Other than the people at MIT.


What scientist would base a theory on one data point?
>

It is not "one data point." It is an hour of deliberate effort to distort
the data and produce a fake version.



> Thus I will vigorously defend the following conjecture:  Alexander
> Parkhomov is neither crazy nor uniformly unprofessional.
>

I do not know if he is uniformly unprofessional, but this particular act
was highly unprofessional. Perhaps everything else he has done was
professional, but this one act is alarming in its own right. By the
standards of U.S. or Japanese science, this is enough to make anyone
suspect he has a screw loose.

I have no idea whether he is crazy or not, but there does not seem to be a
rational reason for doing this. If he was a friend of mine I would be
worried about his mental state.


I am profoundly disappointed to read a scientist write "... It is more like
> a sign of mental illness." based on one data point.
>

Would it be one data point if he held up a liquor store? For a scientist,
deliberately producing and publishing fake data is about weird as armed
robbery would be.



> The above is not meant to attack the beliefs of those who feel strongly
> that Parkhomov has wounded the community.
>

He has not wounded the community. We are not responsible for his actions.
He has made an ass of himself, and hurt his own credibility.

- Jed

Reply via email to