On 30 Dec 2010 18:57:44 -0000
John Levine <jo...@taugh.com> wrote:

> Hey!  I have an idea!  How about if we form the data into a B-tree and
> let people download pages on demand via the DNS?

Nah, I have a better idea... a "B-ish" tree where some nodes can get
out of sync because of caching.  Won't be a problem in practice.
Wait: We'll lower the TTL really low so this isn't a problem!  And
that will not hurt caching efficiency!  Or we'll add a bunch of CNAMEs
to partly patch up the problem... won't be an issue on a
frequently-updated list, for sure.

John, I agree that your draft is clever.  But I think it's really
stretching DNS way beyond what it was designed for and it might be
time to look at a different approach.  To paraphrase the old saying,
when all you have is DNS, every problem looks like a lookup.

Reagrds,

David.

Reply via email to