On Fri, 2008-07-25 at 18:15 +0200, Jonas Eckerman wrote:
> Michelle Konzack wrote:
> 
> >> in short, if someone declares you as their MX (without your 
> >> authorization), you should not start listing clients that try to send 
> >> mail to such domains.
> 
> > Are there ANY leagal reasons to declare someons MX as there MX?
> 
> You miss mouss' point.
> 
> If someone (maliciously or by mistake) declare your system as 
> their MX, innocent third party mail servers may through no fault 
> of their own connect to your system in order to send mail to 
> addresses for wich your system is not a MX.

I think I still miss the point. How can someone else declare the MX of
my domain. ( dns poisoning ignored ). If that were possible , he would
be getting my mails which is much more a serious issue 


Anyway for the stats I just created two brand new "A" records with
mail.domain.com just for testing , and pointed to a fake smtp server 
No Mxes pointing to that IP so no real mail should come here
For the last 3 days , 154 distinct ips have connected and of them 144
are already listed in zen.spamhaus.org

So it doesnt seem to be a very useful effort afterall  to list those
ips :-(. I would have blocked those mails with spamhaus anyway 


Thanks
Ram




Reply via email to