Marc Perkel wrote:


Michele Neylon wrote:

On 2 Jul 2008, at 19:56, Marc Perkel wrote:


Again - it's not to figure out where spam comes from. It's figuring out where non-spam comes from. I think there are registrars out there that don't have any spam domains registered.



What are you trying to prove?

Your logic completely escapes me

I also fail to see how the registrar is of much importance

There are over 900 ICANN accredited registrars

Of those about 200 odd are active

Of the 200 a handful account for the bulk of all domains registered / managed

Statistically this means you're going to see spam from domains registered with enom, godaddy, directi, tucows and a few others. It doesn't mean anything

In fact it's totally meaningless


It's interesting how the concept of white rules seems to be beyond comprehension here. There is a registrar called markmonitor.com that looks like a very high end and expensive registrar that only services big companies like banks and such. So domains who are registered through Markmonitor would not be spammers and would likely be all ham. This isn't about spam detection - it's about ham detection.


The question is, how do you reliably tell that the mail actually came from the from company in question? It can be spoofed, or they can end up with compromised systems.

Reply via email to