Hi 

> In both cases, they don't provide any serious study. they only show 
> numbers that go with their claims. I don't know for others, but my logs 
> don't seem to confirm theirs.

Where do they show numbers? Could not find any.

> and the slowdown thing is based on the theory that spammers have better 
> things to do than wait. now that we know more about botnets, this theory 
> doesn't stand.

I mostly agree with that. My BarricadeMX still catches around 1-2 percent of 
spam due to greet-pause and command-delays (at least on my secondaryMX and most 
customer systems). However this is after 90% of all connection attempts are 
killed due to blacklists anyhow. Without using blacklists this percentage would 
be a lot higher.

Grey listing with content hashing catches around 10% and seems more effective. 

So yes: If their main "benefit" is tarpitting etc. then I agree it probably is 
not worth the money or discussion.


Regards,
 JP

Reply via email to