Gino Cerullo writes:
> part 1.2   text/plain                1027
> On 30-Aug-06, at 1:10 PM, Michael Grey wrote:
> 
> > Are there any SA methods that allow verification of the ‘sender’ of  
> > an email ?
> >
> > I am aware of SPF which can confirm that a host at ip address  
> > x.x.x.x is authorized to send mail as from domain “A”, but how  
> > about a means to confirm that [EMAIL PROTECTED] actually is a  
> > real user before accepting mail from him ?
> >
> I don't believe SA can do that as it's a content filter. Some MTAs  
> can do this and this is were you want those kinds of verifications to  
> happen, before DATA. The problem is that if you do it for every  
> address you will get false positives, especially from sources like  
> mailing lists, news & info subscriptions, etc., and you'll find  
> yourself whitelisting alot.
> 
> I actually do this using Postfix but I use a table of 'frequently  
> forged domains' whose addresses are verified before they are allowed  
> to pass on to the content filters.

It's also worth noting that doing this is counterproductive in an overall
strategy sense, since it drives the spammers to simply use known-valid
third-party addresses -- such as random addrs from their target address
list -- as the forged source of the spam.  The end result for us end
users, is a massive increase in "spam blowback", which is what we've
seen since those MTAs implemented it. :(

--j.

Reply via email to