Thank you everyone for voting. As David pointed out, and Christine relayed privately, there are some concerns about the usage of the Kubernetes trademark in the logo, and violations of some of their trademark rules.
We will discuss this internally, and I will update this thread once decisions have been made. Consider the VOTE paused for now. - Houston On Mon, May 3, 2021 at 10:55 PM Anshum Gupta <ans...@anshumgupta.net> wrote: > (binding) > > logo vote: L-1, L-2 > icon vote: I-3, I-1 > > On Tue, Apr 27, 2021 at 2:00 PM Houston Putman <hous...@apache.org> wrote: > >> Hello Solr users & devs, >> >> The Solr Operator is the first subproject under Apache Solr and thus needs >> a distinguishing logo. >> >> We have multiple options to choose from for both the Solr Operator logo >> and >> icon. These designs have been based off of the Solr and Kubernetes logos: >> >> - https://solr.apache.org/logos-and-assets.html >> - https://github.com/kubernetes/kubernetes/tree/master/logo >> >> The winning Logo and Icon will be finalized with dark & light options, in >> SVG format after they are selected. So please don't factor in blurry lines >> into your vote. >> >> *Please read the following rules carefully* before submitting your vote. >> >> *Who can vote?* >> >> Anyone is welcome to cast a vote in support of their favorite >> submission(s). Note that only Solr PMC member's votes are binding. If you >> are a Solr PMC member, please indicate with your vote that the vote is >> binding, to ease collection of votes. In tallying the votes, I will >> attempt >> to verify only those marked as binding. >> >> >> *How do I vote?* >> Votes can be cast simply by replying to this email. It is a ranked-choice >> vote [rank-choice-voting]. Multiple selections may be made, where the >> order >> of preference must be specified. If an entry gets more than half the >> votes, >> it is the winner. Otherwise, the entry with the lowest number of votes is >> removed, and the votes are retallied, taking into account the next >> preferred entry for those whose first entry was removed. This process >> repeats until there is a winner. >> >> The entries are broken up by type, then entry. The entry identifiers are >> first either "L" for logo or "I" for icon, followed by an id for that >> entry. You can vote for multiple entries, with your highest preference >> sorted first. >> >> Please vote for the logo and icon separately. >> >> (binding) >> logo vote: L-1, L-3, L-4 >> icon vote: I-3, I-2 >> >> *Entries* >> >> All entries are submitted by Mona Chang. >> >> The entries are as follows: >> >> Logos: >> >> [L-1] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/116154447-49f14100-a6ae-11eb-9d05-b4fa7aeb94e6.png >> [L-2] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/116311387-d19f8400-a770-11eb-96da-65891a6df5aa.png >> L-2 is merely an alternative color for L-1. >> [L-3] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/116153995-bf104680-a6ad-11eb-8fee-c29d4612a86c.png >> [L-4] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/116154426-452c8d00-a6ae-11eb-8dc2-080d7b5e04af.png >> >> Icons: >> >> All icons are similar, with different colors and gradients used. >> >> [I-1] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/114226789-ad9f0e80-9939-11eb-97d6-945bf79b8ce7.png >> [I-2] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/116154026-c899ae80-a6ad-11eb-8e47-900adfde9654.png >> [I-3] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/116311474-e9770800-a770-11eb-9402-74e6c1263290.png >> [I-4] >> >> https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/64094885/116154021-c6cfeb00-a6ad-11eb-83c6-384d66500f49.png >> >> Please vote for one logo and one icon from the above choices. This vote >> will close about one week from today, Tue, May 4, 2021 at 11:59PM. >> >> - Houston Putman >> >> This vote is based off of the Lucene logo contest, run by Ryan Ernst. >> > > > -- > Anshum Gupta >
