Nigel Kukard wrote:

>  > If all quotas for all matched policies are applied, then that means
>>  I've got to redefine all my policies to make then mutually exclusive.
>>  That's going to complicate things - but I think it can be done.
>>  
>
>Well ... if a quota is linked to a policy, and the policy is matched ...
>yes ... it will be applied and updated. I don't see it ever working in
>any other way.

Logic to me says it should work down the matched policies in 
descending order until it finds a quota defined - and then apply that 
quota. I suppose the way it's implemented is another way of expecting 
it to work. Perhaps part of the problem is the difference between 
quotas and the way Amavis integration works.

I think the documentation needs updating to make it clear how quotas 
work if multiple policies match a message.


>  > My policies are :
>>  1 Default           0  source = any
>>  6 SASL Users       50  source = $*
>>  9 SASL high volume 55  source = %hi-vol-sasl
>>  7 Int & SASL       60  source = %FI_Network,$*
>>  8 Local mail       90  source = %internal_ips
>>
>>  In general (for sending mail), most customers should be using policy
>>  6, those with higher throughput requirements use policy 9, and
>>  machines on our own network use policy 7.
>>  Locally generated mail should use policy 8
>>  Inbound mail will use the default policy 1
>>
>>  What you are saying then is I'll need to modify them like this :
>  > 1 Inbound           0  source = !$*,!%internal_ips
>  > 6 SASL Users       50  source = $*,!%hi-vol-sasl,!%FI_Network
>>  9 SASL high volume 55  source = %hi-vol-sasl
>  > 7 Int & SASL       60  source = %FI_Network,$*,!%hi-vol-sasl
>>  8 Local mail       90  source = %internal_ips
>>
>>  I believe that should make them mutually exclusive. Nothing matching
>>  %internal_ips will be using SASL. In all cases, destination=all.
>>
>>  Do those look right ?
>>
>>  
>
>I don't see a problem with it :)

I've done that, and it now seems to be working.


-- 
Simon Hobson

Visit http://www.magpiesnestpublishing.co.uk/ for books by acclaimed
author Gladys Hobson. Novels - poetry - short stories - ideal as
Christmas stocking fillers. Some available as e-books.
_______________________________________________
Users mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.policyd.org/mailman/listinfo/users

Reply via email to