I think the question is about passing NULL as a buffer pointer.  E.g.,

MPI_Send(NULL, 0, mytype,dst, tag,comm);

vs

MPI_Send(&dummy,0,mytype,dst,tag,comm);

George Bosilca wrote:

The only restriction the MPI standard impose on the sendcounts and recvcounts arrays is that the values be non-negative, so zero is a legal value.

I don't really understand your second question. Where do you want to use NULL ? In general NULL is not accepted in MPI as an argument for any function ...

On Feb 23, 2009, at 02:55 , jody wrote:

I have an application in which various processes create different
amounts of data (including no data at all).
I have found that MPI_Scatterv and MPI_Gatherv do work with arrays
sendcounts or receivecounts containing zeros.

Since i didn't find the case of 0 sizes in the descriptions
of these functions in the MPI reference, i wondered whether
the use of zeroes is legal or if i was simply lucky that it worked.

An other point: currently i use 1-sized buffers in the
case of a 0-sized data transfer.
Now if 0-sized data transfer is legal, would it be ok to
pass NULL for the buffer?


Reply via email to