Thank you Jay for your note. So JMSAdaptor(or maybe, MQKafkaBridge?) prototype, it is then! Will run a feature compatibility feasibility check.
Thanks Rekha On 3/6/15, 8:45 AM, "Jay Kreps" <jay.kr...@gmail.com> wrote: >I think this is great. I assume the form this would take would be a >library >that implements the JMS api that wraps the existing java producer and >consumer? > >Our past experience has been that trying to maintain all this stuff >centrally is too hard and tends to stifle rather than support innovation. >So if you are interested in doing this I would recommend doing a small >github project. We will definitely help promote it. Several people have >asked for it so I suspect you would definitely get some usage. I would >also >love to hear how well that adaption works in practice--i.e. what >percentage >of JMS features are supportable by Kafka. > >-Jay > >On Thu, Mar 5, 2015 at 6:30 PM, Joshi, Rekha <rekha_jo...@intuit.com> >wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> Kafka is a great alternative to JMS, providing high performance, >> throughput as scalable, distributed pub sub/commit log service. >> >> However there always exist traditional systems running on JMS. >> Rather than rewriting, it would be great if we just had an inbuilt >> JMSAdaptor/JMSProxy/JMSBridge by which client can speak JMS but hit >>Kafka >> behind-the-scene. >> Something like Chukwa's >> o.a.h.chukwa.datacollection.adaptor.jms.JMSAdaptor, which receives msg >>off >> JMS queue and transforms to a Chukwa chunk? >> >> I have come across folks talking of this need in past as well.Is it >> considered and/or part of the roadmap? >> http://grokbase.com/t/kafka/users/131cst8xpv/stomp-binding-for-kafka >> >> >>http://grokbase.com/t/kafka/users/148dm4247q/consuming-messages-from-kafk >>a-and-pushing-on-to-a-jms-queue >> >> >>http://grokbase.com/t/kafka/users/143hjepbn2/request-kafka-zookeeper-jms- >>details >> >> Looking for inputs on correct way to approach this so to retain all good >> features of Kafka while still not rewriting entire application.Possible? >> >> Thanks >> Rekha >>
