I read the documentation for restoring a snapshot into a new cluster.
It got me thinking about replica placement in that context. 
"NetworkTopologyStrategy places replicas in the same data center by walking the 
ring clockwise until reaching the first node in another rack."
It seems it is not enough to restore the token ranges on an equal-size cluster 
since you also need to restore the rack information.

Assume I have two 6-node clusters with three racks for each cluster represented 
by "lower" "UPPER" and "numeric".
In the first cluster the ring is represented by: a -> B -> 3 -> d -> E -> 6 ->
In the second cluster the ring uses the same token ranges and  is represented 
by: a -> b -> C -> D -> 5 -> 6 ->

In this case data restored from the first cluster matches the token 
distribution on the second cluster but does not match the expected replica 
placement.
Token t will reside on nodes a,B,3 on the first cluster but should reside on 
nodes a,C,5 on the second cluster.

Does this make sense? Did I miss something?

Reply via email to