Agree Owem !! Response in both scenarios would depend on the 2 replicas chosen
for meeting QUORUM. But, the intent is to get the tricky part of scenario 1
answered i.e. when 2 nodes selected are one with and one without data.
As per my understanding of Read Path and documentation
https://wiki.apache.org/cassandra/ArchitectureInternals:1. Data would be read
from closest node and digest would be received from one more replica.2. If
mismatch is found between digest, blocked read happens on same 2 replicas (not
all replicas ..so in scenario 2, if 2 nodes didnt have latest data and third
node has it ..still stale data would be returned)
I think these scenarios are still possible even when we are writing at QUORUM
..if we have dropped mutations in our cluster..It was very strange in our case
...We had RF=3 and READ/WRITE CL=QUORUM..we had dropped mutations for long time
but we never faced any scenario like scenario 1 when READ went to node 2 and 3
and read did's return any data..Any comments on this are welcome??
Thanks for clarifying further as discussion could have mislead few..
ThanksAnuj
On Sunday, 28 June 2015 6:16 AM, Owen Kim <ohech...@gmail.com> wrote:
Sorry. I have to jump in and disagree. Data is not guaranteed to retire in
scenario 1. Since two nodes do not have data and two nodes may be the only
nodes queried at that CL, the read query may return data or not.
Similarly, in scenario 2, the query may not return the most recent data because
the node with that data may not be queried at all (the other two may).
Keep in mind, these scenarios seem to generally assume you are not writing data
at consistently at QUORUM CL so therefore your reads may be inconsistent.
On Tuesday, June 23, 2015, Anuj Wadehra <anujw_2...@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
| Thanks..So all of us agree that in scenario 1, data would be returned and
that was my initial understanding..
Anuj
Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android
| From:"Anuj Wadehra" <anujw_2...@yahoo.co.in>
Date:Wed, 24 Jun, 2015 at 12:15 am
Subject:Re: Read Consistency
| M more confused...Different responses. .Anyone who can explain with 100%
surity ?
ThanksAnuj
Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android
| From:"arun sirimalla" <arunsi...@gmail.com>
Date:Wed, 24 Jun, 2015 at 12:00 am
Subject:Re: Read Consistency
Thanks good to know that.
On Tue, Jun 23, 2015 at 11:27 AM, Philip Thompson
<philip.thomp...@datastax.com> wrote:
Yes, that is what he means. CL is for how many nodes need to respond, not agree.
On Tue, Jun 23, 2015 at 2:26 PM, arun sirimalla <arunsi...@gmail.com> wrote:
So do you mean with CL set to QUORUM, if data is only on one node, the query
still succeeds.
On Tue, Jun 23, 2015 at 11:21 AM, Philip Thompson
<philip.thomp...@datastax.com> wrote:
Anuj,
In the first scenario, the data from the single node holding data is returned.
The query will not fail if the consistency level is met, even if the read was
inconsistent.
On Tue, Jun 23, 2015 at 2:16 PM, Anuj Wadehra <anujw_2...@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
| Why would it fail and with what Thrift error? What if the data didnt exist on
any of the nodes..query wont fail if doesnt find data..
Not convinced..
Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android
| From:"arun sirimalla" <arunsi...@gmail.com>
Date:Tue, 23 Jun, 2015 at 11:39 pm
Subject:Re: Read Consistency
Scenario 1: Read query is fired for a key, data is found on one node and not
found on other two nodes who are responsible for the token corresponding to key.
You read query will fail, as it expects to receive data from 2 nodes with RF=3
Scenario 2: Read query is fired and all 3 replicas have different data with
different timestamps.
Read query will return the data with most recent timestamp and trigger a read
repair in the backend .
On Tue, Jun 23, 2015 at 10:57 AM, Anuj Wadehra <anujw_2...@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
| Hi,
Need to validate my understanding..
RF=3 , Read CL = Quorum
What would be returned to the client in following scenarios:
Scenario 1: Read query is fired for a key, data is found on one node and not
found on other two nodes who are responsible for the token corresponding to key.
Options: no data is returned OR data from the only node having data is returned?
Scenario 2: Read query is fired and all 3 replicas have different data with
different timestamps.
Options: data with latest timestamp is returned OR something else???
ThanksAnuj
Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android |
--
Arun |
|
--
Arun Senior Hadoop/Cassandra EngineerCloudwick
2014 Data Impact Award Winner
(Cloudera)http://www.cloudera.com/content/cloudera/en/campaign/data-impact-awards.html
--
Arun Senior Hadoop/Cassandra EngineerCloudwick
2014 Data Impact Award Winner
(Cloudera)http://www.cloudera.com/content/cloudera/en/campaign/data-impact-awards.html
|
|
|
|
