-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 All,
I've been using ant for ... ever. And I just got caught by something that I didn't expect. I've come to expect that property values cannot be changed after they have been set; that is, they are write-once and then they are constants. Due to a mistake in a somewhat complicated build file, I discovered that pattern sets can be redefined in a way that is fairly surprising to this seasoned ant user. For example: <target name="foo"> <echo>${toString:property.file.pattern}</echo> <patternset id="property.file.pattern" includes="**/*.properties" /> <echo>${toString:property.file.pattern}</echo> <patternset id="property.file.pattern" includes="**/*.xml" /> <echo>${toString:property.file.pattern}</echo> </target> Running this target will produce the following output: foo: [echo] ${toString:property.file.pattern} [echo] patternSet{ includes: [**/*.properties] excludes: [] } [echo] patternSet{ includes: [**/*.xml] excludes: [] } Surprised? I definitely was. My problem was that I had a target somewhere with something similar to: <copy toDir="{dir}"> <fileset dir="${properties.dir}"> <patternset id="property.file.pattern" /> </fileset> </copy> Without realizing it, the above lines will redefine the patternset called "property.file.pattern" to contain *nothing*. Oops. Definitely my mistake, but ... I didn't really expect that ant would allow me to override the previous definition of the patternset. Is this intentional? Or should patternset definitions also be immutable similar to property values? Thanks, - -chris -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - https://www.enigmail.net/ iQIzBAEBCAAdFiEEMmKgYcQvxMe7tcJcHPApP6U8pFgFAl5ISnEACgkQHPApP6U8 pFhKIg/+Lz9O0+CziqHFQ1+3cV9BAaMGiSRE2iDTRlxEPW9bDYie1cVwbrs6/NPm UZZguCBKyna/qUoym+nGf3DqCoop79DFGacajIde35K2bCClZx2p3m6VCDvrFB8j LCYcT2AgJrZYxvMIVVMMY5h1B9hzXCJol5VnjHLCakrwJtG4pLWxbkJ1ZlOUh7wM qO39f6prH+4hpRdBKpFEG8UEg66Ywm33o9TNDy07qPpIyIJu8Zn/Fs3ttY6TVhfW e4oav1aG+15nLi8QYpNQiMwoOzyWwb8rhJr2yLfTwBoynYfZMvbb4UsWDHaAIrjF 5LelZuOCVAyo/GMTkyrKddTZ4irBqa5X0Oxma2Lh7TJyzZtU3zpKak+aYhsfJ9/e cvr11srZxpyj66CTOUEM16FAzujEqrRiV5kxs/oFisEMYgESm2qgib5+JBxeBQ6D AI3K2JoscF958fGqphFCaYrk4KhOVoCFV4twz19xdJWyMvTjo01mxXKivrh3Aptm 9mS/PGt7VRIr8XSVhkRPvZq7adJxvfKinB1Y4NT2bGb1RmWHcVACwVVqRTbLRoAM Z/NmMHDCf3YjA4+PwgbrrD5eG53rF0JBLBvOlQQ3sAJF16+pc+CKm4ZahWuO4Nii cv42PVm2bhrAfXDC54ACHZqVs/EPrKCsppLy2FwSsqa5xk3UAPE= =Zkat -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: user-unsubscr...@ant.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: user-h...@ant.apache.org