> Maybe I should have said emoji are fan-driven.

That works.  Here's the previous assertion rephrased:

  We should no more expect the conventional Unicode character encoding
  model to apply to emoji than we should expect the old-fashioned text
  ranges to become fan-driven.

And if we don't want the text ranges to become fan driven, as pointed out by Martin Dürst and others, we take a cautious and conservative approach to moving forward with the standard.

Veering back on-topic, the anti fan driven aversion doesn't apply to encoding italics, although /fans/ would benefit.  There's pre-existing conventions for italics, and a scholar with the credentials of Victor Gaultney should be able to make a credible proposal for encoding them.  I hope we haven't overwhelmed him with a surplus of rhetoric.

Reply via email to