On 03/20/2014 06:38 AM, Jean-Baptiste Lallement wrote: > Le 20/03/2014 12:11, Dave Morley a écrit : >> On 20/03/14 06:51, Didier Roche wrote: >>> Le 19/03/2014 23:54, Victor Thompson a écrit : >>>> Could we hold off on promoting the image until this bug is resolved as >>>> well: https://bugs.launchpad.net/music-app/+bug/1292306 >>>> I believe it should be a blocker since it affects the lifecycle of the >>>> music-app. >>>> >>>> Victor >>> >>> I'll let QA decides if this is a blocker or not. >>> >>> However, from what I foresee, I wouldn't advise to block on that as: >>> - there was no automated test for it (and thanks for your branch with >>> the test, that will be guarded now! ;)) >>> - it wasn't part of the daily dogfooding until now, so we couldn't >>> ensure this was working for every images (maybe it should as well?) >>> - the impact is smaller than the risk of waiting any longer for a >>> promotion and holding off other transitions that are piling up. >>> >>> We'll have to wait a little bit anyway for the other blockers to be >>> settled down, so there is still time for the whole community to work on >>> that bug if any solution is found before QA vetoed or +1 this piece of >>> advise. >>> >>> Cheers, >>> Didier >>> >> >> I consider this a minor issue and not a blocker. It is annoying but the >> community team behind the app are pretty responsive. There is a bug in >> place for it and Alan informs us that the team are aware of the bug so >> it should be dealt with shortly. >> >> Also because it is a click app the change can land at any time once >> there is a fix in place and it isn't bound by the image rules of some of >> the application. >> > > +1, Not a blocker for QA. For the reasons stated above and essentially > because, > from an image perspective, the impact of this issue, while annoying for the > users of the music-app, is limited and it would block other transitions. > I'm not saying this should be a blocker, but it would be nice if someone said they were looking at the issue while it is declared as a non-blocker. I've not looked at it, but my limited understanding of the description and the fact that one of the music-app developers believes this is not a bug in the music-app suggests this is an issue in the platform itself. Not to mention, it is installed be default on the images.
Speaking as a dogfooder who uses the phone (and the music-app) every day, it seems like this has the potential to turn into another terminal-app situation where it was broken but declared a non-blocker, only to have months go by without a fix. Letting this through without someone actively looking at it would be disappointing. 2 cents -- Jamie Strandboge http://www.ubuntu.com/
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
-- Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~ubuntu-phone Post to : ubuntu-phone@lists.launchpad.net Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~ubuntu-phone More help : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp
