Hi Sebastien (2013.01.21_20:27:29_+0200) > >Upload rights at the moment conflate membership and upload rights. > >Therefore, the board has to evaluate the qualifications for both. > > Right, Bjoern is applying for upload right so it seems logical he > gets reviewed in context of upload rights...
Upload rights currently go with membership, so applicants have to be reviewed in the context of both. We'll tell the applicant, if we think granting membership would be hard, or if we think upload rights aren't suitable yet and they should be applying for membership only. > >We will be sending Bjoern an E-Mail explaining our concerns and ways > >that he can address them. > When is that planned? He still didn't get those, we still have no > clue what to change, As soon as we can. And I think the idea of looking for things to change is short-sighted. If we don't think someone is ready, it usually means they need to do some more good distro work, and show that they are ready. > and meanwhile he has a SRU and a raring update blocked waiting... Nobody is blocked from working on Ubuntu, without upload rights. That's what sponsorship is for - if you don't have upload rights, you prepare an upload and find someone who has the upload rights to sponsor your upload. In this case, besides his usual sponsors, bdrung has offered to review and sponsor libreoffice uploads, which is he has already been working on. Stéphane also provided some feedback yesterday. > I appreciate that the job is not easy, your reply doesn't address > the concerns I raised in my initial email though. We still have a > community member who has been working full time on maintaining a > difficult package for 1.5+ years, got endorsement from 3 members, > and he got rejected mostly for "lack of devel releases" and an wrong > assumption (no review) ... isn't the project just making the bar too > high to join there? I was absent from the meeting that declined his application, but I wouldn't agree with your synopsis of the reasoning behind it. I think the reasons are wider, and we'll do our best to explain them in a private e-mail to him. SR -- Stefano Rivera http://tumbleweed.org.za/ H: +27 21 461 1230 C: +27 72 419 8559 -- ubuntu-devel mailing list ubuntu-devel@lists.ubuntu.com Modify settings or unsubscribe at: https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-devel
