After thinking about it some more I guess I must be confused as to why
we are installing Recommends by default at all if we don't want packages
that should be in the "Recommends" line to be in recommends any more due
to recommends being installed by default.

"Recommends: Used for packages that are highly recommended and usually
are installed with the package. Some package managers, most notably
aptitude, automatically install Recommended packages."

The openoffice.org package is a meta-package that is really intended to
install all of openoffice.org so (imho) really all of openoffice.org
should be in the Depends line with the exception of translations. There
was talk in the past to demote openoffice.org-base out of the Depends
line (iirc). I think the real solution should be not to install
'openoffice.org' using the installer if we don't want the user to have
all of openoffice.org (wrt filters etc since the user won't normally
find these on their own). However, I do agree that the packages other
than openoffice.org like openoffice.org-common (wrt styles) shouldn't
have these Recommends so that it is easier to separate out what doesn't
need to be installed.

I am open to other ideas/discussion about this topic. And I do agree
there is a real bug here in that some of the packages (other than the
'openoffice.org' meta-package) have Recommends that should be demoted.

I hope the above made sense to more than just me... :-)

-- 
excessive Recommends
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/159133
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is the bug contact for Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to