Hi all,

After reading about all these woes and experiencing it myself, I have
done some further experimenting in order to isolate the problem and as a
result I have found a very EASY WORKAROUND which in no way impacts on
your computer.

MY SETUP:
Hardware:  HP 2133 Mini-note netbook computer
Fresh install of Ubuntu 9.04
Using internal wireless modem with Broadcom STA driver for wifi access

PROBLEM:
After booting up and providing relevant information and password I can connect 
wirelessly.
If I leave the PC for a while and return then I find that the wireless 
connection is down and there is no way I can get it up again except rebooting, 
very inconvenient.
This problem did NOT exist in Ubuntu 8.10.

ACTIONS:
I searched the Ubuntu Forum and discovered that many, many others reported a 
similar or identical problem on many differenct hardware platforms.
Some had discovered that if they closed their laptop computer which switched 
off the screen, then they were immediately disconnected from the network and 
needed to reboot to get back on again.
Some therefore were pointing to the openchrome graphics driver (I find it 
amazing that a graphics driver should somehow interfere with the wireless 
driver).
So, the general consensus was developing that it had to do with the openchrome 
video driver and suggestions were to fall back to the vesa driver. I tried that 
and it did indeed prevent the problem form occuring, so further pointed a 
finger at openchrome.

I rebooted with openchrome again and then experimented this way:
I opened 
System/Preferences/Screensaver/Power Management
 and set it as follows:
"Put display to sleep when inactive for" and set it to "2 minutes".
I waited 2 minutes, the screen blanked without closing the laptop lid.
I woke it up by moving the mouse and tried if I still had a wireless connection 
up - NO - wireless connection was DOWN.

WORKAROUND:
I rebooted and again opened
System/Preferences/Screensaver/Power Management
 and set it as follows:
"Put display to sleep when inactive for" and set it to "never".
Now the wifi connection stays UP, it has not gone down even once!!!

But when I leave the machine I would like it to blank the screen after, say, 5 
minutes.
So I simply set the "Screensaver theme" to "Blank screen" after 5 minutes, and 
the screen blanks but when I move the mouse and check my wireless connection 
the it is still UP and running!!!

Andrew Aylett sent me this link (thanks, Andy):
http://www.openchrome.org/trac/ticket/288
If you go there you will see there is a patch made available for the openchrome 
driver and at least one HP2133 user has tested it and reports that it has fixed 
the problem.
My problem is, I don't know how to apply such a patch and since my computer now 
stays connected, I am not very keen to experiment with it.
What I am hoping is that one of the clever Ubuntu system guys will make the 
patch available for all of us to download and install the usual way via 
synaptic or one of the other update managers after rigorous testing.

This is the kind of problem I find extremely frustrating and if newbies
have this problem, then it might likely turn them off Ubuntu and perhaps
Linux in general. This problem was reported by Ben McCann in February
and perhaps by others too that early and here we are now in May and the
problem has not been fixed. Is that good enough? Well, I have been a
applications project manager for about 25 year and I would not have
accepted this situation. Anyway, now we know where the problem lies, so
please let us have a fix for it.

-- 
[HP 2133 MiniNote laptop] Unexpected and unrecoverable wireless disconnect with 
B43 driver
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/331952
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to