Hi, This records my thoughts after a discussion with Ilias & Heinrich re memory allocation in U-Boot.
1. malloc() malloc() is used for programmatic memory allocation. It allows memory to be freed. It is not designed for very large allocations (e.g. a 10MB kernel or 100MB ramdisk). 2. lmb lmb is used for large blocks of memory, such as those needed for a kernel or ramdisk. Allocation is only transitory, for the purposes of loading some images and booting. If the boot fails, then all lmb allocations go away. lmb is set up by getting all available memory and then removing what is used by U-Boot (code, data, malloc() space, etc.) lmb reservations have a few flags so that areas of memory can be provided with attributes There are some corner cases...e.g. loading a file does an lmb allocation but only for the purpose of avoiding a file being loaded over U-Boot code/data. The allocation is dropped immediately after the file is loaded. Within the bootm command, or when using standard boot, this would be fairly easy to solve. Linux has renamed lmb to memblock. We should consider doing the same. 3. EFI EFI has its own memory-allocation tables. Like lmb, EFI is able to deal with large allocations. But via a 'pool' function it can also do smaller allocations similar to malloc(), although each one uses at least 4KB at present. EFI allocations do not go away when a boot fails. With EFI it is possible to add allocations post facto, in which case they are added to the allocation table just as if the memory was allocated with EFI to begin with. The EFI allocations and the lmb allocations use the same memory, so in principle could conflict. EFI allocations are sometimes used to allocate internal U-Boot data as well, if needed by the EFI app. For example, while efi_image_parse() uses malloc(), efi_var_mem.c uses EFI allocations since the code runs in the app context and may need to access the memory after U-Boot has exited. Also efi_smbios.c uses allocate_pages() and then adds a new mapping as well. EFI memory has attributes, including what the memory is used for (to some degree of granularity). See enum efi_memory_type and struct efi_mem_desc. In the latter there are also attribute flags - whether memory is cacheable, etc. EFI also has the x86 idea of 'conventional' memory, meaning (I believe) that below 4GB that isn't reserved for the hardware/system. This is meaningless, or at least confusing, on ARM systems. 4. reservations It is perhaps worth mentioning a fourth method of memory management, where U-Boot reserves chunks of memory before relocation (in board_init_f.c), e.g. for the framebuffer, U-Boot code, the malloc() region, etc. Problems —------- There are no urgent problems, but here are some things that could be improved: 1. EFI should attach most of its data structures to driver model. This work has started, with the partition support, but more effort would help. This would make it easier to see which memory is related to devices and which is separate. 2. Some drivers do EFI reservations today, whether EFI is used for booting or not (e.g. rockchip video rk_vop_probe()). 3. U-Boot doesn't really map arch-specific memory attributes (e.g. armv8's struct mm_region) to EFI ones. 4. EFI duplicates some code from bootm, some of which relates to memory allocation (e.g. FDT fixup). 5. EFI code is used even if EFI is never used to boot 6. EFI allocations can result in the same memory being used as has already been allocated by lmb. Users may load files which overwrite memory allocated by EFI. Lifetime -------- We have three different memory allocators with different purposes. Can we unify them a little? Within U-Boot: - malloc() space lives forever - lmb lives while setting out images for booting - EFI (mostly) lives while booting an EFI app In practice, EFI is set up early in U-Boot. Some of this is necessary, some not. EFI allocations stay around forever. This works OK since large allocations are normally not done in EFI, so memory isn't really consumed to any great degree by the boot process. What happens to EFI allocations if the app returns? They are still present, in case another app is run. This seems fine. API –-- Can we unify some APIs? It should be possible to use lmb for large EFI memory allocations, so long as they are only needed for booting. We effectively do this today, since EFI does not manage the arrangement of loaded images in memory. for the most part. It would not make sense to use EFI allocation to replace lmb and malloc(), of course. Could we use a common (lower-level) API for allocation, used by both lmb and EFI? They do have some similarities. However they have different lifetime constraints (EFI allocations are never dropped, unlikely lmb). ** Overall, it seems that the existence of memory allocation in boot-time services has created confusion. Memory allocation is muddled, with both U-Boot code and boot-time services calling the same memory allocator. This just has not been clearly thought out. Proposal —------- Here are some ideas: 1. For video, use the driver model API to locate the video regions, or block off the entire framebuffer memory, for all devices as a whole. Use efi_add_memory_map() 2. Add memory attributes to UCLASS_RAM and use them in EFI, mapping to the EFI_MEMORY_... attributes in struct efi_mem_desc. 3. Add all EFI reservations just before booting the app, as we do with devicetree fixup. With this model, malloc() and lmb are used for all allocation. Then efi_add_memory_map() is called for each region in turn just before booting. Memory attributes are dealt with above. The type (enum efi_memory_type) can be determined simply by the data structure stored in it, as is done today. For example, SMBIOS tables can use EFI_ACPI_RECLAIM_MEMORY. Very few types are used and EFI code understands the meaning of each. 4. Avoid setting up EFI memory at the start of U-Boot. Do it only when booting. This looks to require very little effort. 5. Avoid calling efi_allocate_pages() and efi_allocate_pool() outside boot-time services. This solves the problem 6. If memory is needed by an app, allocate it with malloc() and see 3. There are only two efi_allocate_pages() (smbios and efi_runtime). There are more calls of efi_allocate_pool(), but most of these seem easy to fix up. For example, efi_init_event_log() allocates a buffer, but this can be allocated in normal malloc() space or in a bloblist. 6. Don't worry too much about whether EFI will be used for booting. The cost is likely not that great: use bootstage to measure it as is done for driver model. Try to minmise the cost of its tables, particularly for execution time, but otherwise just rely on the ability to disable EFI_LOADER. – Regards, Simon
