On Jan 4, 2010, at 7:18 PM, Kevin Horn wrote:

> Thanks to a quick patch from Michael Thompson, the current output of the 
> Sphinx conversion [1] now matches the color scheme and typographic style of 
> the main twisted site.  It's using the layout of the 'default' sphinx theme 
> (previously was using the 'sphinxdoc' theme).

This is an improvement, but it looks like a very rough cut to me.  The link 
colors are wrong, it's missing the subtle top/bottom gradients, there's no 
Twisted logo anywhere, etc etc.  

> I'd like to know what people out there want/expect the final theme of the 
> Sphinx version of the Twisted docs to look like.

Well, if it ended up looking more or less like it does now, but with a bit more 
attention to detail (at a minimum: some gradients, matching colors, a little 
global navigation to get you back to some Trac pages) I'd be happy, and it 
would be an upgrade.

However, ideally, the page would include links to 
<http://twistedmatrix.com/trac/chrome/common/css/trac.css> and 
<http://twistedmatrix.com/trac/chrome/common/css/wiki.css>, and use the CSS 
classes defined there in its own HTML templates.

While this isn't the cleanest CSS in the world, using it would have two 
significant benefits:

  1. lots of little details, like fonts, colors, sizes, etc, which would be 
exhausting for anyone to investigate and enumerate completely, would line up 
correctly and make it look more polished, and
  2. if we changed the CSS to adjust the look of the trac site, the docs would 
adjust with it.

I don't mind if this means that some HTML needs to be copied and pasted 
directly from either Trac's templates or Trac's output, as long as it is a 
quick 2-minute cut/paste/edit job that can be quickly explained in a comment 
for someone wanting to update it to a new theme.  I'd much rather have a 
still-slightly-inconsistent documentation theme than burn weeks copy/pasting 
hundreds of little things out of the trac HTML and pain-stakingly re-creating 
every minor effect on the Trac site.

Thanks for all the good work!


_______________________________________________
Twisted-Python mailing list
Twisted-Python@twistedmatrix.com
http://twistedmatrix.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/twisted-python

Reply via email to