Hi, there's a bug report [1] complaining that Ctrl+R on a message from a mailing list but with a Reply-To pointing elsewhere replies to the list, not to the Reply-To address.
This can be changed so that a Reply-To overrides List-Post when activating "reply by guess". However, that would not be much consistent with messages to MLs which do not have Reply-To, as Ctrl-R would still respond to the MLs in this case, not just to the author. That could, of course, be changed as well, but I'm not terribly inclined to do so simply because the whole point of "reply by guess" is to, well, guess what to do based on a set of heuristics. I really like Ctrl-R going to mailing lists. "You could always press Ctrl-L to reply to list" is not a great answer because one could always press Ctrl-Shift-A to use a private reply. I start to believe that having the buttons for changing the reply type within the actual composer would be best here (like a combobox "Reply goes to the ML", "Replying privately", "Replying to all but me", "Respondents picked by hand") is the only reasonable way to go which would make more users happy. Or do we want a checkbox in the settings for what Ctrl-R shall do, like "take a guess (preferring mailing lists and group replies)", "reply to all recipients but me", "reply to everybody", "try to produce a private reply"? Or do we want both? And who's gonna write that patch? :) Cheers, Jan [1] https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=320816 -- Trojitá, a fast Qt IMAP e-mail client -- http://trojita.flaska.net/
