Thanks for the feedback. On Fri, Sep 22, 2017 at 05:46:36PM -0000, bp wrote: > You can skip this paragraph if you're in a hurry. First, thank you for > holding this discussion in the open. I totally understand the marketing > reasons for this: I depend on Canonical's distribution, and want Canonical > to offer their paying customers a fantastic out-of-the-box experience so > that they can continue to offer their services to the general public, too.
I want to be clear that, although Canonical benefits financially from users signing up for paid extended support through ESM, the rationale for including the package in ubuntu-minimal is not a "marketing" one. Rather, the intent is to ensure users who have opted into the paid ESM service have a seamless process for enabling it on their system. We do want users whose systems are EOL and no longer security supported to know what their options are (upgrades, or paid ESM), but including ubuntu-advantage-tools in ubuntu-minimal is not intended to discourage users from upgrading. > That said, the ubuntu-advantage-tools package is not in fact strictly > necessary to allow the machine to boot, detect hardware, connect to a > network, install packages or perform basic diagnostics. With ubuntu- > minimal 1.400, this is now essentially a mandatory piece of software > that will, at best, emit an error message. There are a number of packages pulled in by ubuntu-minimal that could be removed and still technically fulfill the capabilities listed in the package's description; they would just make it more inconvenient and awkward to do so. ubuntu-advantage-tools certainly falls under the header of 'install packages' - which is more than can be said of e.g. the tzdata and locales packages. As far as emitting error messages: while none of the package services currently provided by this tool are available on non-LTS releases, it is not impossible that these would be available in the future depending on commercial demand. In the meantime, I think it's a far better user experience to run the documented command and be told 'this service not available for this release' than to try to run it and be told 'command not found', and it was with this in mind that I supported including this package in non-LTS releases. > Would changing the relationship from Depends to Recommends meet your > requirements (automatic setup on every Ubuntu machine) while allowing > manual removal of the package? We would have to verify this empirically. I'm not altogether opposed to it, but I also don't see what advantage it brings our users. The ubuntu-advantage-tools package is: Installed-Size: 36.9 kB Download-Size: 11.3 kB and has zero added dependencies. And most of the current size is the archive keys, which if they weren't in ubuntu-advantage-tool would certainly be in ubuntu-keyring (and indeed, we might still move them there), which is also part of ubuntu-minimal. So from a technical point of view, what benefit is there to making the package removable? I would note that it would be entirely possible to bundle these scripts with some other base package; and I think it's really only because this is a separate package that it attracts notice and invites the suggestion to make it removable. Otherwise, having one more command in /usr/bin that goes unused would not be cause for concern. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Touch seeded packages, which is subscribed to ubuntu-meta in Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1686183 Title: Ship ubuntu-advantage in ubuntu-minimal Status in ubuntu-advantage-tools package in Ubuntu: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-meta package in Ubuntu: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-advantage-tools source package in Precise: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-meta source package in Precise: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-advantage-tools source package in Trusty: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-meta source package in Trusty: Confirmed Status in ubuntu-advantage-tools source package in Xenial: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-meta source package in Xenial: Confirmed Status in ubuntu-advantage-tools source package in Yakkety: Won't Fix Status in ubuntu-meta source package in Yakkety: Won't Fix Status in ubuntu-advantage-tools source package in Zesty: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-meta source package in Zesty: Confirmed Status in ubuntu-advantage-tools source package in Artful: Fix Released Status in ubuntu-meta source package in Artful: Fix Released Bug description: The ubuntu-advantage-tools package is a bit odd as it was first landed in precise to support the ESM effort inside canonical. [0] In order to bring this package up to date across other series in ubuntu, it has been recommended by the Ubuntu Foundations team to land into trusty next, then forward-port pocket-copy to all supported series until we get to the devel release. The version here: https://github.com/CanonicalLtd/ubuntu-advantage- script/releases/tag/v2 ... has all on-disk bits correctly working, for all series, but no-ops on any release other than precise (ESM is only for "unsupported" LTS releases as it were). This is a request to land ubuntu-advantage- tools into trusty, then pocket-copy it to supported series of ubuntu once that is finished. [Impact] * Allow ubuntu-advantage users to access the extended security maintenance script with a simple command line tool. This script needs to hit precise machines and be easy for ubuntu-advantage customers to enable, thus basefiles was chosen as a home. [Test Case] * Run ubuntu-advantage, it should print out help * Run sudo ubuntu-advantage enable <token> (without sudo it will warn you), but you need to be an ubuntu-advantage customer to get that token. In the end, the script simply adds and removes an /etc/apt/sources.list.d entry. * Verify that the MOTD does not contain any mention of ubuntu- advantage esm or precise and its end of life * Verify that ubuntu-advantage enable-esm <token> installs needed dependencies: - create the following file and its contents to have apt not install recommended packages by default: $ cat /etc/apt/apt.conf.d/no-recommends APT::Install-Recommends "false"; - remove ca-certificates and apt-transport-https: $ sudo apt remove ca-certificates apt-transport-https - run sudo ubuntu-advantage enable-esm <token> and verify that the two removed packages are reinstalled * you can contact me (d...@canonical.com) if you would like a token for test purposes. [Regression Potential] * Low, this is a new script, not included in any automated startup paths. [Other Info] * http://blog.dustinkirkland.com/2017/03/ubuntu-1204-esm.html [0] https://insights.ubuntu.com/2017/03/14/introducing-ubuntu-12-04 -esm-extended-security-maintenance/ To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/ubuntu-advantage-tools/+bug/1686183/+subscriptions -- Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~touch-packages Post to : touch-packages@lists.launchpad.net Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~touch-packages More help : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp
