Don I’m afraid your information is not accurate, SAL is the same as a K9AY, the two wires close to each other can be removed because they cancel each other. The remain wires works like two vertical in phase, as the same in any flag, loaded loop or pennant. The cardioid pattern is the same.
The is no implementation of two SAL in phase because it does not work, the phasing system is too complex to phase two SAL. If you know the people that actually tested the antenna, you know that the claimed RDF was never achieved. The RDF of the K9AY is the same of the SAL, the EZENEC does a horrible job with loops close to the ground. Saying that, both antennas are excellent receiver antennas if you don’t have anything else. 73’s JC N4IS Sent from Mail for Windows From: Don Kirk Sent: Thursday, January 6, 2022 7:19 PM To: W0MU Mike Fatchett Cc: topband Subject: Re: Topband: K9AY Loop Questions Hi Mike and gang, It has been a long time since I looked at the SAL in which I modeled it with the help of the designer of the SAL (KB7GF). The SAL is actually different than the K9AY and other EWE types of RX antennas which have a typical RDF value of around 7.8 because the SAL (Shared Apex Loop) antenna actively uses two of its loops which are "in line" with each other for what you might call the primary direction (direction in line with the loops), and these two phased loops can provide an RDF value of around 9.2 depending on the coupler locations. For the off axis directions (45 degrees to the loops) I believe all 4 loops of the SAL are active (phased together) and they provide a pattern more like what you would expect from the K9AY or other EWEs with an RDF of approximately 7.8. Therefore in the 4 primary directions of the SAL the SAL definitely has a better RDF than the K9AY or other types of EWE receiving antennas. When used "in line" the RDF of the SAL is around 9.2 as mentioned above which is similar to what you would obtain using two phased verticals with 1/8 wavelength spacing. Just FYI, Don (wd8dsb) On Wed, Jan 5, 2022 at 9:43 PM W0MU Mike Fatchett <[email protected]> wrote: > The SAL is pretty much just an AY loop with a more functional > controller? I have had moderate success with a pennant at V31 as well. > > W0MU > > On 1/5/2022 7:23 PM, [email protected] wrote: > > I tried an AY loop decades ago, without the Array Solutions adjustable > > termination controller, and I do not remember it being that useful for > RX. > > The antenna is ground dependant so perhaps it works better for some than > > others. Even a short Beverage may be a better choice. From my P40A > station I > > used a Pennant with decent results. It was inexpensive to build and not > > ground dependant however it only covered one direction. The Array > Solutions > > Shared Apex Loop Array has great reviews and may be worth considering, > Pete. > > > > John KK9A > > > > > > > > Pete Smith N4ZR wrote: > > > > I recently installed a K9AY loop (with the Array Solutions controller), > > and have a couple of questions. Installation is pretty standard, with a > > fiberglass pole at the center, ground rod at its base, and on the ground > > radials under each direction of the loop. > > > > The antenna is directional, as demonstrated by tuning in broadcast > > stations at the high end of the AM band and separating stations on the > > same frequency so that I can hear one or the other. Atmospheric noise > > is 1-2 S units more on my inverted L than on the K9AY antenna, but > > signal strengths of stations in the favored direction of the loop seem > > about the same or a bit lower than the inverted L. The Termination > > adjustment is working, to judge by the switching transients, but seems > > to make little or no difference. > > > > How do these results compare with others' experience? I didn't expect a > > "magic bullet", but the K9AY loop seems a little bit underwhelming. > > > _________________ > Searchable Archives: http://www.contesting.com/_topband - Topband > Reflector > _________________ Searchable Archives: http://www.contesting.com/_topband - Topband Reflector _________________ Searchable Archives: http://www.contesting.com/_topband - Topband Reflector
