Re: Separating Service code from Tomcat 4.0

[Remy Maucherat]

> ME BIG DOPE :) :) :) There are TWO Win32 Service implementations... I
> thought Joe and Elijah were working on the same code :) :) :) But THEY'RE
> NOT! (Sometimes I'm just so fuckin' stupid! :)
>
> On a very rough analysis, Elijah's JavaService is better as it uses JNI,
but
> on the other hand, Joe's TomcatService is better because the sources are
way
> simpler, even though it uses the batch files...

Ok, but JavaService looks perfect to me :
- Uses JNI indeed
- Service installation / removal works great
- Pipes the out and the err of the JVM process into logs files in
CATALINA_HOME/logs (good)
- Logs stop / start / trouble to the NT event log
- Very generic

Remy