Hi folks, I wanted to provide an update on draft-ietf-tls-esni. I went through all existing PRs and issues as well as some of the recent list discussion. This message provides a summary of the status:
PRs * 594: A first proposal to fix the no-sni section [Arnaud Taddei] I think this is fine and will merge on 2/24 unless people object. * 602: More explanatory text [EKR] This is a pretty substantial rewrite of the overview section to address some of the clarity issues raised by Arnaud Taddei. This is editorial, but needs review. * 603: Clarify that you can fall back by providing no ECH in EE [EKR] This addresses a point made by Elardus Erasmus about what indicated you're disabling ECH. Hopefully this is uncontroversial. Arnaud also provided two editorial PRs with clarifications (587 and 588). I believe that these are addressed by 602. ISSUES * 866: Server retry flow, section 7.1 [Robert Sayre] I'm not seeing support for a change here, so I propose to close unless someone provides a PR that receives some support. * 591: Can we clarify the Misconfiguration section? [Arnaud Taddei] This is addressed in PR #602, so I propose to close it once that lands. Finally, Erlardus Erasmus raised some issues around limiting retries ( https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/tls/bvvWbtxJAiMfilfy32EvdaCszQ4/). I have filed an issue with some thoughts at: https://github.com/tlswg/draft-ietf-tls-esni/issues/604 I think this needs some discussion before we have a PR. Assuming that there are no strong objections to the resolutions of the PRs and issues above and we can get consensus on Issue 604, I should be able to spin a WGLC-ready version of ECH before the draft deadline. -Ekr
_______________________________________________ TLS mailing list TLS@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/tls
