Hi All,
I will just add my 2-cents on this matter. While I haven't directly
contributed many patches to tcc, I have personally hacked on it a fair bit
for side projects and follow the mailing list closely.


> I was wondering if the TCC project has any sort of guidelines on
> commits, and specifically regarding LLM code.


 I've also been thinking along similar lines that LLM use should be
clarified for the project.


> As a result I guess TinyCC, since it doesn't seem to be focused on
> implementing a huge feature set with pressure to compete with "big"
> compilers, may want to consider banning LLMs.


I agree with this sentiment, albeit less for legal reasons and more for
practical and personal ones.
The practical reason being that, we don't have enough contributors to
strongly vet any LLM generated code that comes into the project.
With a manually generated commit there is at least some expectation of
correctness and testing (although perhaps I'm being a touch optimistic).
I don't think this assumption holds at all for LLM generated commits.

Secondly, I just don't think LLM generated code is a good fit for this
project which is intended to be small and hackable.
>From my (limited) experience, while each LLM addition may look okay on the
surface, eventually it degrades the quality of the codebase, which isn't
something I want to deal with in TCC.

For my part, I would like to restrict LLM based contributions.

Thanks,
-Sam Ellicott
Soli Deo Gloria
_______________________________________________
Tinycc-devel mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.nongnu.org/mailman/listinfo/tinycc-devel

Reply via email to