Klemens Nanni <[email protected]> wrote:

> rarpd(8) is small enough where my impression is that refining it a
> little would be good, but it quickly comes down to personal taste.

And I continue to disagree.

Another example of the same pattern is ifconfig.  Here you will see it
is not documented that [-a] is incompatible with [interface], but the
program does actually enforce it (refuses to act).

Even later in the man page, this is not actually described.  Yet noone is
dying from this.

The synopsis / usage language simply cannot describe this, and I argue
that it SHOULD NOT describe the situation, because past attempts at
being complete precise have made the SYNOPSIS / usage cluttered, and
thus less valuable to the users.

Another way of looking at it is that the grammer is permissive, rather
than proscriptive.

So I suggest you get over it.

Reply via email to