Pardon par ecrire en anglais, mais ma francaise n'est pa bon. I build regularly routable maps of France for Garmin devices (you can download them from [1]. During the process to generate the maps, I get a list of turn restrictions that are tagged/constructed incorrectly. I attach the list in the hope that some of you would like to fix these restrictions, improving the quality of OSM data and Garmin maps. Numbers shown in the list are OSM data ID's, so it's easy to find them. Regards Carlos
[1] http://mapas.alternativaslibres.es/descargas.html Turn restriction 37007 lacks 'via' node and the 'from' (27658094) and 'to' (27658096) ways don't connect Turn restriction 28801 has multiple 'to' members - first 'to' member is 25394422 Turn restriction 28801 has multiple 'to' members - first 'to' member is 25394422 Turn restriction 3104 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 47,65464/-2,75662, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 3104 'from' way (7837494) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,65464/-2,75662) Turn restriction 3314 'to' way (4708529) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,64996/-2,71886) Turn restriction 16534 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,08445/-1,62323, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 16534 'from' way (23655048) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,08445/-1,62323) Turn restriction 16535 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,08415/-1,62295, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 16535 'to' way (23655048) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,08415/-1,62295) Turn restriction 18432 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,10473/-1,66454, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 18915 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,04821/-1,58832, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 18915 'from' way (24626217) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,04821/-1,58832) Turn restriction 19051 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,10568/-1,66597, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 28788 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,77689/-3,04272, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 28801 lacks 'via' node and the 'from' (26433466) and 'to' (25394422) ways don't connect Turn restriction 31509 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 49,18867/-0,36459, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 91885 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,11018/-1,67406, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 10046 has multiple 'via' members Turn restriction 10046 has multiple 'via' members Turn restriction 11775 has multiple 'to' members - first 'to' member is 4039206 Turn restriction 11776 has multiple 'from' members - first 'from' member is 22759360 Turn restriction 11762 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,86378/2,38234, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 11762 'to' way (4039159) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,86378/2,38234) Turn restriction 11774 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,84502/2,32028, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 11774 'from' way (23981735) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,84502/2,32028) Turn restriction 11774 'to' way (4039919) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,84502/2,32028) Turn restriction 11775 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,84358/2,32438, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 11775 'from' way (5213138) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,84358/2,32438) Turn restriction 11775 'to' way (4039206) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,84358/2,32438) Turn restriction 11776 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 48,84373/2,32442, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 11776 'from' way (22759360) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,84373/2,32442) Turn restriction 26867 'to' member should be a Way but is a NODE: 36150986 @ 43,02905/2,96708 Turn restriction 38024 unknown member role '' Turn restriction 92837 'to' member should be a Way but is a NODE: 360300399 @ 44,13633/4,79796 Turn restriction 23779 lacks 'restriction' tag (e.g. no_left_turn) Turn restriction 26216 'from' way (25509528) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (42,69133/2,70686) Turn restriction 26217 'to' way (25509528) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (42,69156/2,70757) Turn restriction 26864 'to' way (32074195) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,03134/2,96929) Turn restriction 26865 'to' way (32074700) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,02898/2,96704) Turn restriction 26866 lacks 'restriction' tag (e.g. no_left_turn) Turn restriction 26866 'to' way (32074700) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,02989/2,96745) Turn restriction 26868 'from' way (32074700) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,03119/2,96772) Turn restriction 30417 'to' way (25563841) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (42,68377/2,85080) Turn restriction 30768 lacks 'restriction' tag (e.g. no_left_turn) Turn restriction 92540 'to' way (32074700) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,01892/2,97056) Turn restriction 92541 'from' way (32074403) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,01750/2,97470) Turn restriction 92547 'from' way (32074700) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,01377/2,97193) Turn restriction 92548 'to' way (32074700) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (43,01414/2,97212) Turn restriction 92836 'to' way (32091154) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (44,13633/4,79796) Turn restriction 92838 'to' way (32091154) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (44,13624/4,79993) Turn restriction 92839 'from' way (32091154) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (44,13624/4,79993) Turn restriction 92841 'from' way (32091176) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (44,13133/4,79111) Turn restriction 93264 'to' way (32127025) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (44,27186/4,70290) Turn restriction 54454 has multiple 'from' members - first 'from' member is 28705449 Turn restriction 54456 has multiple 'from' members - first 'from' member is 28705449 Turn restriction 145821 has multiple 'from' members - first 'from' member is 34926733 Turn restriction 47860 'from' way (27996676) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,75598/7,29996) Turn restriction 47860 'to' way (27812739) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,75598/7,29996) Turn restriction 54454 'from' way (28705449) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,74506/7,34511) Turn restriction 54456 'from' way (28705449) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,74484/7,34537) Turn restriction 110279 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 47,74197/7,34861, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 110279 'to' way (27942642) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,74197/7,34861) Turn restriction 133828 'from' way (26210500) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (46,17985/6,13865) Turn restriction 145821 'from' way (34926733) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,23484/6,01238) Turn restriction 145928 'from' way (28841558) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,23780/6,01491) Turn restriction 54454 has multiple 'from' members - first 'from' member is 28705449 Turn restriction 54456 has multiple 'from' members - first 'from' member is 28705449 Turn restriction 17245 'to' way (24856634) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,56968/7,76319) Turn restriction 17246 'from' way (24856634) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,56968/7,76319) Turn restriction 17248 'from' way (24181572) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,57133/7,76431) Turn restriction 17249 'to' way (24181572) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,57210/7,76497) Turn restriction 17250 'from' way (24181572) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,57210/7,76497) Turn restriction 29802 'to' way (15707567) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,56549/7,75948) Turn restriction 29803 'from' way (15707567) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,56549/7,75948) Turn restriction 29978 'from' way (23069564) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,59525/7,71790) Turn restriction 47860 'from' way (27996676) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,75598/7,29996) Turn restriction 47860 'to' way (27812739) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,75598/7,29996) Turn restriction 47882 'from' way (28000376) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,77422/7,38017) Turn restriction 47882 'to' way (28000375) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,77422/7,38017) Turn restriction 47883 'from' way (28000560) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,77259/7,38069) Turn restriction 47883 'to' way (28000282) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,77259/7,38069) Turn restriction 47884 'from' way (28000963) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,77282/7,38075) Turn restriction 47884 'to' way (28000965) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,77282/7,38075) Turn restriction 54454 'from' way (28705449) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,74506/7,34511) Turn restriction 54456 'from' way (28705449) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,74484/7,34537) Turn restriction 110279 lacks 'via' node (guessing it should be at 47,74197/7,34861, why don't you add it to the OSM data?) Turn restriction 110279 'to' way (27942642) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (47,74197/7,34861) Turn restriction 162025 'to' way (20354915) doesn't start or end at 'via' node (48,19799/7,52149) _______________________________________________ Talk-fr mailing list Talk-fr@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-fr
