Please decide which edit you are proposing to run, you mentioned two contradictory algorithms. And then actually propose it.
For the record, I oppose deprecating wikimedia_commons and removing it with a bot. We would start to specify both commons_category and commons_file? "Changesets will be kept small ie. country size bbox maximum." - this in my opinion far too large, bbox should be far smaller. Jun 25, 2020, 19:57 by pang...@riseup.net: > > > > Från:> pangoSE <pang...@riseup.net> > > Skickat:> 25 juni 2020 19:49:58 CEST > > Till:> tagg...@lists.openstreetmap.org > > Ämne:> Automated edit of image tags suggestion > > Below is a copy of the text at:> > https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Automated_edits/pangoSE#Key:image > > > Key:imageEdit > > There are serious problems with the use of this key in the database. > > I recently started discussing the problems related to urls and > File:filename.* that links to wikimedia_commons using the tag. See > Talk:Key:image#Discourage_linking_to_commons_files_and_migrate_all_File:filename..2A_values_and_direct_urls_to_wikimedia_commons > and tagging. > > Algorithm 1Edit image=File:* -> wikimedia_commons=File:* image=Category:* -> > wikimedia_commons=Category:* image=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:* > -> wikimedia_commons=File:* > image=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:* -> > wikimedia_commons=Category:* > > There are some image= tags that link to multiple images separated by ";". > These will be manually migrated to contain only one image that is not linking > to commons and the rest in a note, note1, noteX if multiple urls. > > There are some elements like > https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/674919702> > that both link to a commons category with wikimedia_commons= and an > additional image= that links to one of those images. I will not touch this as > it would probably be best to introduce new tags commons_image and > commons_category for this usecase like Yurik did in the tagging discussion. > > There are some urls that link to a category and the media viewer. This is not > always working (see [1]) but will not be touched by this edit as there have > not been a discussion of this practice yet to my knowledge. > > Algorithm 2Edit > > Based on suggestions by Yurik of separating the file and category references. > > image=File:* -> commons_file=File:* image=Category:* -> > commons_category=Category:* image=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:* > -> commons_file=File:* image=https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:* -> > commons_category=Category:* > > Note commons_file could also link to a video. > > There are some image= tags that link to multiple images separated by ";". > These will be manually migrated to contain only one image that is not linking > to commons and the rest in a note, note1, noteX if multiple urls. > > There are some elements like > https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/674919702> > that both link to a commons category with wikimedia_commons= and an > additional image= that links to one of those images. These will be changed to > commons_file and commons_category. > > There are some urls that link to a category and the media viewer. This is not > always working (see [2]) but will not be touched by this edit as there have > not been a discussion of this practice yet to my knowledge. > > Affected featuresEdit > > This edit will affect about 80,000 elements in the database. There are > >80,000 image= tags with links to wikimedia commons where 50,000 of them is > in Germany alone. > > ExecutionEdit > > Changesets will be kept small ie. country size bbox maximum. For Germany > there are ~50150 so there I will keep the bbox region sized. > > I will use JOSM to make the changes using find/replace. > > DiscussionEdit > > > > Discussion > > > > > > > > > > Last edited 5 months ago by PangoSE > > > > OpenStreetMap Wiki > > Content is available under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 > license unless otherwise noted. > >
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
