sent from a phone > On 15. Apr 2020, at 03:17, Joseph Eisenberg <joseph.eisenb...@gmail.com> > wrote: > > But it takes more time for each mapper to add 2 tags instead of one. > Mapper time is the most precious resource in OpenStreetMap: we don't > have enough mappers, and most are working for free, for fun. > Let's make things as easy as possible for mappers: one tag for one main > feature.
most time is spent finding the “best” or at least mostly used and appropriate tagging, much more than you need to actually type it in. And people relying on presets don’t care anyway, because a preset can set 2 tags with one click. I agree we should strive for easy tagging, but it may also imply to sometimes use 2 tags rather than one. When there are places where an insurance company office lets you sign up for health insurance and other insurance types, the distinction in the main tag will be an issue. I am not completely sure, but from a quick verification it doesn't seem improbable that you can get healthcare insurance at the same place as other insurance types, e.g. when you look here for offices of a specific German insurance company (which offers "all" kinds of insurances, including private healthcare insurance) in a specific town, the search form does not have a selection for the type of insurance, hence I would suspect that all of them will be able to sell you all of their insurances: https://www.allianz.de/agentursuche/karlsruhe/?address=karlsruhe I am still not completely sure, but I believe, "Allianz" is a group here, and health care insurance will be provided by a member of this group, and agents will sell you any product the group offers (i.e. in the details they are different "companies", but you can find several of these companies together, bundled as "group"). Also, the assumption for your assessment of easyness is that people will want to tag "healthcare insurance company office", so they will need 2 tags to describe office=insurance, insurance=health(_care) but if all the mapper wants to tag is "insurance company" (regardless of types of insurances), she could add office=insurance which is arguably simpler and easier than office=health_insurance So, in accordance with your statement "Let's make things as easy as possible for mappers", we could argue just as well for "office=insurance" and optional details about the kind of insurance in additional tags. Cheers Martin _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
