On 21/3/20 9:00 am, Graeme Fitzpatrick wrote:



On Fri, 20 Mar 2020 at 21:55, Jan Michel <j...@mueschelsoft.de <mailto:j...@mueschelsoft.de>> wrote:

    Yes. We shouldn't have a separate tag for each and every company that
offers such services.

No, that get's very unwieldy, very quickly, especially when you get several different ways of spelling the same thing, as just demonstrated with PO boxes.


Here Post offices are the only ones that 'deliver' to PO Boxes. Very few outside contractors interface with the Post Office to enable PO Box delivery. Similar comments for RMBs etc. I think similar comments applies to other PO Boxes around the world?

For remote places again few contractors would be delivering to a specific place, they usually contact the place and have them come and pick up from their 'local' depot.

That trip can be a few hours there and a few hours back. For this reason most remote places prefer the official Post Office delivery system as it gets the mail closer to them.


As for different ways of spelling/formatting. Mistakes will occur just as they do in naming streets with 'Rd' or 'rd' rather than Road. In any country where there is an officially desired spelling/format then that can be referenced and values corrected to it.


For 'other' delivery providers they may prefer to use the other addr keys?


I refer to the 'address' of t|he Barkly Homestead;
|
"PRIVATE MAIL BAG 32
Tennant Creek
Northern Territory  0862

Australia"


At present within OSM there is no contact nor address information there.

https://www.barklyhomestead.com.au/

For other deliveries?

" 19.7107° S, 135.8275° E

Situated on the Barkly Highway

between Tennant Creek - NT and Camooweal - QLD"

Note - no house number, lot number etc... locals and those traveling through will simply 'know' of its location.


    The value of the tag should be what needs to be on
    the address label and this has to contain information on the kind
    of box
    or the operator.


Yep, in whichever format it appears

The format may change from country to country. I listed what is officially accepted by the Post Office here.

OSM will need to accept that formats will change, as may the language.

I am occasionally questioned when sending things overseas as to the address, it being particularly long.

My relatives assure me that it is correct and needed to ensure correct delivery.


On Fri, 20 Mar 2020 at 21:32, Paul Allen <pla16...@gmail.com <mailto:pla16...@gmail.com>> wrote:

    How about
    addr:mail or addr:delivery?


I'd suggest addr:mail= whatever you want to list out of all of Warin's options (+ undoubtedly more)!


Whatever key is used there will need to be some sort of format of the value to identify CRLF, particularly if the key is to carry the entire address (country, postcode, state, town/city/ etc) in the format wanted by the delivering organization. I am assuming that the complete address will need to be placed here as it may vary from what is entered in the other addr tags.

_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Reply via email to