> re we going to discuss this on the mailing list, or in the wiki discussion > page, or both, or what?
"Both" is probably the realistic option. We can't require anyone to login to wiki.openstreetmap.org to comment on this idea, though I do think the discussion there would be easier to follow. > aeroway=airstrip This feature is not currently rendered by any maps that I am aware of. > Many outback homesteads (ranches) have an [aerodrome] with more uses and also > usually provides refuelling and basic primitive aircraft services. This would probably be aerodrome=private, since it's not open to anyone else other than the ranch / station owners and their invited guests, I imagine? Adding access=private would be recommended. - Joseph On 9/10/19, Colin Smale <[email protected]> wrote: > Point of order, also with half an eye on the "tagging governance" > discussion.... Are we going to discuss this on the mailing list, or in > the wiki discussion page, or both, or what? I suggest focussing on a > single platform, and placing a notification on the other platform > directing readers to the other platform, if you see what I mean. > > On 2019-09-10 10:32, Warin wrote: > >> On 10/09/19 17:35, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: >> >>> I've started a new proposal for Key:aerodrome. >>> >>> See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Key:aerodrome >>> >>> This proposal uses aerodrome=* for classification of an >>> aeroway=aerodrome as an international airport, other commercial >>> airport, general aviation aerodrome, private aerodrome, or airstrip. >>> >>> It would deprecate aeroway=airstrip and aerodrome:type=* >>> >>> Values to be approved: >>> * aerodrome=international - already common >>> * aerodrome=commercial - new tag >>> * aerodrome=general_aviation - new tag (default type) >>> * aerodrome=private - already common >>> * aerodrome=airstrip >>> >>> Currently the IATA code is quite helpful for finding commercial >>> airports which offer scheduled passenger flights, but a few aerodromes >>> with an IATA code do not have commercial flights. >>> >>> It would be helpful to know which airports have international flights, >>> and the tag aerodrome=international has already been used over 1000 >>> times. >>> >>> aerodrome=airstrip is better than aeroway=airstrip, because an >>> airstrip is still a type of aerodrome. >>> >>> aerodrome=private is already widely used, but I'm also recommending >>> adding access=* >> >> Here there are 'international' and 'domestic' airports. I think 'domestic' >> might be better than 'commercial'??? >> >> I have no idea what a 'aerodrome=private' is. I think this could include >> airports used for skydiving .. so open to the public. Arr it is also on >> the proposal page sorry. It is a confusing value, no idea of a better >> term. There are also sailplane airstrips used to launch and land >> sailplanes. The launching may be done by a 'tug' aircraft. They can be >> open to the public for joy flights in tandem sailplanes. >> >> Many outback homesteads (ranches) have an airstrip for their own use. This >> use can be to get to the shops, the neighbours, mail deliveries, farm >> duties and for the flying doctor. This goes beyond the proposaled >> aerodrome=airstrip, in that it has more uses and also usually provides >> refuelling and basic primitive aircraft services. >> I think the reason why aeroway=airstrip is use is so that it does not >> render until zoomed in. Yes, a rendering issue taken care of by tagging. >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Tagging mailing list >> [email protected] >> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
