>> The tag livestock=* >> used 132 times > > 16% of landuse=farmyard have a animal=* tag.
I think you misread taginfo. There are over 800,000 landuse=farmyard features, and only 1764 have an animal=* tag, so that is 0.22% - the 16% on the right means that 16% of uses of animal are found on landuse=farmyard. If we remove the animal=yes tags, there are about 247 uses of animal=* on landuse=farmyard, landuse=meadow, and landuse=farmland combined, so it's not huge. I'd be happy to use either animal=* or livestock=*, myself, but I was concerned that they wide variety of uses for the animal=* key would be a problem with getting a proposal approved. Joseph _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging