Hello. 2019年5月11日(土) 5:30 bkil <bkil.hu...@gmail.com>:
> I've read in the previous rejection comments that many opposed to > putting brand details in keys. What do you think about this version: > prepaid_top_up:mobile=yes/<brands>. The reason is that around here, > you could top up your mobile phone either at the given carrier, kiosks > over generic online charging or at given supermarket chains > (supporting fixed subsets of carriers). We could easily map such > detail when importing the given supermarket chain's data. We have > already raised this question during previous imports before this > proposal was started. > > I'm in favor for your idea of putting brand details. The reason is mainly because: *【There should be consistency between prepaid_top_up tag and payment tag.】* https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:payment For example, there are many kinds of public_transport cards in the world and payment:* tag supports them. (icsf cards like Suica in Japan, Oyster card in the UK, T-money card in Korea and so on.) A tag like prepaid_top_up:public_transport=yes is insufficient, We cannot use Oyster card in Japan! Where you can use Suica, there should be top_up machines for it. Other types of rechargeable cards or mobile phone applications may be more limited in use. I proposed using prepaid_top_up:gaming=yes in the discussion page, but more specific tags like prepaid_top_up:gaming=paseli sound better for me. Paseli is operated by Konami, so it cannot be used in games by other companies(Sega, Taito,...). Thank you. Takayuki Ishino yumean1...@gmail.com >
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
