On Thu, Jun 11, 2015 at 4:52 AM, Paul Johnson <ba...@ursamundi.org> wrote:
>
> On Thu, Jun 11, 2015 at 2:52 AM, johnw <jo...@mac.com> wrote:
>
>> I would hate for a gas station icon to pop up somewhere where I couldn’t
>> access it with normal transportation or not really be a “gas station”
>
>
> Devil's advocate: For quite a few people (particularly in the pacific
> northwest, the arctic, and other exceedingly rural and vast locales),
> flight would be "normal transportation." Rural airstrips, particularly
> those without a fenced perimeter, may have a fuel station that could very
> well also serve up fuels for ground transportation.
>
There's no need for the devil here. There are many tagging solutions,
including simply placing two
gas station nodes near each other, one for each style of pump.
But the nice thing about aeroway=fuel is that it works so cleanly to
represent this edge case:
name=Bob's Airport, Seaplane, Boat and Motorhome Gas Depot
*amenity*=fuel
*aeroway*=fuel
*waterway*=fuel
brand=BP
fuel:100LL=yes
fuel:diesel=yes
fuel:autogas=yes
website=http://bobdoesitall.example.com/
No confusing "motorhomes=no", "boats=yes" subtags on amenity=fuel. No
confused GPS users
searching for fuel, and ending up driving across the runway. No stupid gas
icons showing up in the middle
of the airport on a car oriented map.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Here's a JOSM patch for to implement just that preset:
+ <item name="Aviation Fuel" icon="presets/fuel.png"
type="node,closedway" preset_name_label="true">
+ <link href="http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:aeroway=fuel
"/>
+ <space />
+ <key key="aeroway" value="fuel" />
+ <optional>
+ <combo key="brand" text="Brand"
values="Agip,Aral,Avia,BP,Chevron,Citgo,Eni,Esso,Exxon,Gulf,Mobil,OMV,Petro-Canada,Pioneer,Q8,Repsol,Shell,Socar,Statoil,Sunoco,Tamoil,Texaco,Total,Independent"
values_searchable="true" />
+ <label text="Fuel types:" />
+ <checkgroup columns="2">
+ <check key="fuel:91UL" text="91UL (clear)" />
+ <check key="fuel:96UL" text="96UL (clear)" />
+ <check key="fuel:100LL" text="100LL (blue)" />
+ <check key="fuel:diesel" text="Diesel" />
+ <check key="fuel:autogas" text="Ethanol-Free Unleaded"
/>
+ </checkgroup>
+ </optional>
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
