2013/2/6 Philip Barnes <p...@trigpoint.me.uk>: > I would go for building=shelter rather than amenity. > > > Amenity would imply it is available for anyone passing with a horse to take > shelter.
I think this would put more implication into amenity than what it practically has in OSM (see e.g. amenity=parking, access=private or amenity=prison or ...) I'd go for the more specific building=field_shelter (but also building=shelter if you prefer) for the building-tag, or also building=roof if mostly open. amenity=shelter would be OK for me Don't find shelter_type a very good choice (IMHO it would be more logical to use shelter:type, but checking actual usage "shelter_type" is the established key). Also the value "field" is not very appealing (sounds as if the "field" itself is a kind of shelter). So trying to remove ambiguity as much as possible you could tag this: building=field_shelter (or building=roof, layer=1) amenity=shelter shelter_type=field_shelter cheers, Martin _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
