Le 19/10/2010 02:40, Ulf Lamping a écrit : > Am 18.10.2010 12:20, schrieb Rodolphe Quiedeville: >> Le 18/10/2010 09:31, Rodolphe Quiedeville a écrit : >>> Hi, >>> >>> I started rename amenity=fire_hydrant to emergency=fire_hydrant as it is >>> describe in the wiki. I checked there's no rendering in mapnik styles >>> and t...@h. >> [...] >> >> I forgot to say that I've opened a ticket to fix the JOSM presets : >> >> http://josm.openstreetmap.de/ticket/5537 >> >> If someone could say to me how to fix the Merkaartor presets too, I'll >> do my best to do it too. > > There has been a very lengthy discussion about the emergency category - > and there wasn't a clear outcome. There wasn't a consensus if the change > is useful at all and it's still unclear what should be in the emergency > category and what not. > > Then the Wiki was changed without community consensus. Then you seem to > have made a mass edit without following the code of conduct about mass > edits. > > > Now you have the nerve to tell the JOSM developers: "The key for fire > hydrant is false, it's emergency=fire_hydrant instead of > amenity=fire_hydrant, here a patch to fix the default presets" > > > The JOSM presets are correct and don't need to be fixed. Please revert > the wiki and your mass edit changes back to it's original state! > > The developers have better things to do than these wiki fiddling > nonsense ...
To explain what I've done. I read the wiki as you and the page http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Tag:amenity%3Dfire_hydrant&redirect=no was last modified on 6 August 2010, at 22:18 by someone else. If you read all the documentation on the wiki (not wrote by me, I done juste the french translation) could you say that it is not what to follow ? After that I propose a patch to JOSM developpers, what I do wrong ? I propose to improve the software to be conform with the tags definition. I posted here what I'm doing on the mass edits (edits really simple to reverts), give me an url to improve my knwoledge about mass edits, I'll read it with pleasure. I read the thread about amenity=emergency_phone ! Not about fire_hydrant, but perhaps my not so good english (I'm french) was a problem for good understanding. I read the rules of mapnik and t...@h to see if this tags is rendered at the moment. So why are you so agressive with me ? Are you sure all the contributors will do all I've done before editing tag or ways ? Now to fix eventual problems, please fix this wrong wiki to avoid future problem, and after that I'll revert my changes and add amenity=fire_hydrant to all node I've changed. I have better things to do, than read agressive emails on mailing-lists... OSM is a beautiful project and always a pleasure to contribute. -- Rodolphe Quiédeville - Artisan Logiciel Libre Travailleur indépendant spécialisé en logiciel libre http://rodolphe.quiedeville.org/ SIP/XMPP : rodol...@quiedeville.org _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
