It looks like you have come up with good solutions to all of the issues raised.
-------Original Email------- Subject :Re: [Tagging] shop=wedding_office >From :mailto:simonbi...@yahoo.com.au Date :Tue Sep 28 22:00:09 America/Chicago 2010 Noel David Torres Taño <env...@rolamasao.org> wrote: > Bussiness that sell bride dresses only shop=clothes clothes=wedding_dresses > Bussiness that sell ceremonial dresses (bride and bridmaiden, groom, black > tie, >New Year, cocktail dresses... men and women, even childs) shop=clothes clothes=ceremonial > Bussiness that sell decorative wedding stuff (decorations, bouquets, chair >covers) but no dresses shop=boutique boutique=wedding > Bussines that organize weddings in your name (buy wedding stuff, flowers, >gifts, contract photographer, musicians, catering, restaurant) office=wedding_planner > Bussiness that do more than one of the previous Let's take "all of the above" as the pathological example. At the top level it's both an office and a shop. The office is a wedding planner office. The shop is both a boutique and a clothes shop. The boutique is a wedding boutique. The clothes include both wedding dresses and ceremonial clothes. Noting the general consensus that a multi-valued key a=b;c should be avoided and rewritten as a:b=yes a:c=yes I therefore propose: office=wedding_planner shop:boutique=yes boutique=wedding shop:clothes=yes clothes:wedding_dresses=yes clothes:ceremonial=yes This is equivalent mathematically to an expression like office (wedding planner) + shop (boutique (wedding) + clothes (wedding dresses + ceremonial)) PS: if you remember that ceremonial clothes includes wedding dresses, you can remove wedding dresses and simplify to: office=wedding_planner shop:boutique=yes boutique=wedding shop:clothes=yes clothes=ceremonial _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
