Hai all

Syslog-reliable, is more or less a secured version of syslog. But it's
also a "modern" protocol. It uses mime, it uses XML, etc.

Those modern influences are simply great. BUT, ...
The current proposition is also very old-fashioned. It allows only a
very limited set of facilities and severities. It want/needs short
messages (at least, I understand the log-messages are still limited to
1024 bytes), etc.

Why aren't XML'ed priorities possible? Why shouldn't we at least
_suggest_ to use XML'ed log-messages?
Why are daytimes still without year (sure, we don't have a year 2000
problem, this way :-). Why do we think a second is long; even when a PC
operates at speeds 1000000000 times faster (1Ghz)?
Even Windos know about "daylight saving time" now; and about
time-zones. 
But modern logging still forbids sometime more clever then localtime.

Sure, we need to be compatible. But doesn't that mean syslog-reliable
can transport/use old style messages. It does!
But, It see no reason to define a modern logging-system, that's  only
goal is to be compatible. Can't we do that better.

I suggest to redefine those parts that are limiting, and/or
old-fashioned. And to skip those limits. *BUT* require (in the
document, and in our work) that t is still possible to
 1) use (old) syslog-syslog messages in a modern syslog-reliable environment
 2) operate a modern syslog-reliable environment such, that parts can
    be implemented with old style, limited, utp syslog-syslog
    components (relay, collector) WHEN NEEDED.

This means, we can intermix syslog-syslog and syslog-reliable
components. That we can use a modern protocol, which it's (security)
enhancements, as syslog once was made. 
AND, that we have a (syslog) logging system that can be used (again)
for years and years. New "userland features" etc can be rolled out,
when needed. 

This also enhances the security of the system. Modern security is also
about "looking ahead". Comparing several logs, of several site, and
locations. This does require a better timestamp then the current 15
byte, which is all that is ALLOWED now!


See you


---GAM
"This should be a jolly quote"
====
Do NOT send MS-Word or other MS-bits to me!
I can read them now, but I still don't like it.

Reply via email to