Dear iptel,
Thankyou for your open source website and excellent information. I hope you are
able to help me with the following.
We are an Australian organisation. We are trying to find a good quality SIP
provider, commercial grade, with high connectivity success rates. We have used
Skype, and it works incredibly well. It gets through your firewall and succeeds
with login and successful voice and video call connection just about every
time. But every public or commercial SIP Service I have used has failed to
perform as well. Both the open source and the commercial SIP servers all suffer
from the same problems:
a.. they don't login unless you open up port 5060 on your firewall,
regardless of whether STUN or TURN or ICE is in use
b.. they don't reliably connect each call, sometimes the calling end just
keeps ringing, and the receiving end doesn't ring
c.. even if a call gets connected, they often have one of the 4 A/V streams
missing, eg. we get video and outgoing audio, but no incoming audio
d.. when one party hangs up, sometimes the other end sometimes doesn't know
about it and just sits there thinking the call is still underway
e.. when the Internet is busy, eg. at 4pm when children get home from school
and jump on the Internet, their media relays struggle to keep up and UDP
streams are badly degraded
Note that we have not yet tried iptel.org, but I note that video is not talked
about much on your website, and also you are an open source organisation, who
cannot be expected to provide a commercial grade service. (If I am wrong about
this, please tell me and I will certainly give iptel.org a try!)
Using Jitsi, Linphone, and many other softphones, we have tried ....
a.. ippi.fr
b.. jumblo.com
c.. pennytel.com
d.. opensips.org
e.. sip.linphone.org
f.. an Australian commercial VoIP service by MyNetFone (works very well, but
voice only)
We are a business, and we are prepared to pay for a SIP Service. We cannot use
ooVoo, Tango, Goober, ippi Messenger and other closed applications. We have to
use an open source softphone such as Jitsi or Linphone, because they have an
API. So my questions are ....
a.. Are you aware of any commercial grade SIP providers that work as well as
Skype:
a.. they have STUN / TURN / ICE support in place
b.. they support both video and audio calls
c.. login occurs reliably:
a.. regardless of where I am located (at home, at work, on my smartphone,
using WiFi at a hotel, etc.)
b.. regardless of what firewall I am behind
d.. call connection occurs reliably, regardless of where I am located and
regardless of firewall
a.. every call always connects
b.. if codecs at each end match, the call successfully connects audio and
video streams both ways
c.. when one party hangs up, the other end knows about it and doesn't
just sit there thinking the call is still underway
e.. their servers and infrastructure performs well even at peak periods,
for example at 4pm when all the children get home from school and jump on the
Internet
f.. they have high performance media relays in place, so that audio and/or
video can be relayed if required
b.. If no company or organisation offers a SIP Service that performs as well
as Skype, can you recommend any company or individual that we can engage (pay)
to establish our own SIP Service. They must have the skills to setup SIP
Server, STUN Server, TURN Server, and to adjust ports and settings so that
anybody can login and make a call from anywhere, behind any firewall.
Your recommendations would be very much appreciated.
Thankyou,
Karl Grimm.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Karl Grimm, Managing Director
Mobile: 0418 310 989 | k...@konnekt.net.au
Konnekt
feel connected, feel safe
_______________________________________________
SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list
sr-users@lists.sip-router.org
http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users
