On Mon, Jan 09, 2012 at 11:00:36AM -0500, Marc-André Lureau wrote: > Hi > > > I think Marc-Andre wanted / already uses git-bz (Owen Taylor's > > extension > > iirc) but maybe it's not contradictory. Can it be setup so bug email > > still goes to the mailing list? can someone using mailing list to > > review > > a patch and reply with inline comments, like we do so far, interact > > with > > someone using gerrit? > > I know gerrit review could be made with inline reply. However, you lose a bit > of the functionnality that makes it worth it (contextual diff, diff of diff > etc..). > > The main concern I have with using gerrit is that it will be one more thing > to watch / to use. > > Since we already use bugzilla for bug reports, it's much easier to use it for > patches too. With splinter & git bz, you have very good integration already > (although not as good as gerrit). > > Bugzilla comments/patches can be subscribed to receive by mail.
That's individual subscribers. I wouldn't subscribe the whole list because the bz emails are much more verbose. Actually that's exactly what qemu-devel does, they use launchpad but the same idea, i.e. they subscribed the list. Same goes for mesa (although they use bugzilla I think). I disklike personally reading those bugzila/launchpad generated emails, they are not as readable as an inline reply to a patch. Otoh I understand that this is simply because I'm consuming it via email, not the main interface for either of those, and for gerrit as well. No, I don't have any solution :/ _______________________________________________ Spice-devel mailing list Spice-devel@lists.freedesktop.org http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/spice-devel
